Biodiversity Data Journal :
Taxonomy & Inventories
|
Corresponding author: Giorgi Epitashvili (giorgi_epitashvili@iliauni.edu.ge)
Academic editor: Paramasivam Kodeeswaran
Received: 27 Jan 2023 | Accepted: 19 Apr 2023 | Published: 30 May 2023
© 2023 Giorgi Epitashvili, Bella Japoshvili, Levan Mumladze
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Epitashvili G, Japoshvili B, Mumladze L (2023) Ponticola alasanicus sp. n. (Gobiiformes, Gobiidae) from the Alazani River Basin, Georgia. Biodiversity Data Journal 11: e101095. https://doi.org/10.3897/BDJ.11.e101095
|
The South Caucasus Region and Georgia, in particular, is a biodiversity hotspot and characterised by high diversity of landscapes and ecosystems, as well as high levels of endemism. At the same time, diversity of freshwater organisms in the region remains poorly studied, including fishes. The freshwater fish fauna of the South Caucasus Region consists of 119 fish species, of which 13 species belong to the order Gobiiformes. It should be noted that gobies are amongst the poorly studied taxa in Georgia and probably unknown/undescribed species still living in the Georgian freshwater ecosystems which requires further research.
Ponticola alasanicus, a new species is described from the Alazani River, western Caspian Sea Basin, Georgia. It is distinguished from its congeners in the Caspian and Black Sea Basins by having the following features: dorsal fin with VI-VII spines and 15½-16½ branched rays, anal fin with 10½-12½ branched rays; lateral line with 48-55 scales; laterally compressed body with dark brown and black blotches - scales ctenoid; first and second dorsal fins almost touching with dorsal fins bases; head large, depressed, wider than deep, its length approaches almost 3.4th of standard length; nape scaled completely; cycloid scales cover upper part of opercle, cheeks noticeably swollen; snout longer than eye, eye diameter 4.5 times its head length; lower jaw slightly protruding; upper lip is uniform; pelvic disc short, elongated and flat, not reaching the anus; the pectoral fins extends vertically through first branched dorsal fin; caudal fin rounded. Ponticola alasanicus sp. n. belongs to P. syrman group and it is separated by a minimum Kimura 2-parameter distance of 3.5, 3.6 and 4.8% from P. syrman, P. iranicus and P. patimari, respectively.
Ponticola alasanicus sp. n., freshwater gobies, DNA barcoding, taxonomy, Western Caspian Sea Basin
The family Gobiidae Cuvier, 1816 is one of the most diverse group of vertebrates and includes 257 valid genera with more than 2000 species (
During a recent field collection event in 2020 in eastern Georgia, we collected goby specimens from the Alazani River, which were preliminarily identified as P. cyrius. However, later CO1 DNA barcoding showed substantial differences with other known Ponticola species from Georgia and surrounding regions. Based on further detailed investigation of the collected material, in the following, we decide to provide a description of a new Ponticola species from eastern Georgia.
Study area
The Alazani River is one of the largest in the Kakheti Region (eastern Georgia), which currently drains into the Mingachevir Reservoir. The first detailed ichthyological research on this river was conducted in the 1950s and 20 fish species were recorded (
All along the Alazani River, floodplain riparian forests have developed where small streams originate drained from the surrounding mountains. Such tributaries are often called “Psha” amongst Georgian locals (which means cold clear stream). The water temperatures in these Pshas are constant throughout the year and thus create perfect living conditions for many aquatic species. The biodiversity of these streams is generally poorly understood.
Data collection
During the regular ichthyological fieldwork in August 2020, one of those Psha, Tsitsmatiant Psha, was sampled and specimens of gobies of the genus Ponticola were collected. Fish were caught using the electrofishing device EFGI 650 (http://www.electric-fishing.de/efgi6_e.html) under a permission from the Ministry of Agriculture and Nature Protection of Georgia (permission number: 5768/01). In total, five specimens of gobies were collected in the location and after anaesthesia with MS-222 of a subsample of the collected fishes, a fin-clip was taken and stored in 99.9% molecular grade ethanol for molecular genetic study and specimens were fixed in 70% ethanol for morphological investigation. In 2020-2022, we also conducted three additional field surveys in different seasons at the Tsitsmatiant Psha and collected an additional 15 goby specimens and preserved these in the same way. The collected specimens are kept in the collection of Hydrobiology and Ichthyology Department of the Institute of Zoology of Ilia State University under the instituional code HID-ISU.
DNA barcoding
The genetic study was conducted under the ongoing project - Caucasus Barcode of Life (CaBOL - https://ggbc.eu/) with standard CaBOL protocol. In particular, genomic DNA was extracted from pectoral fin clips using a BioSprint96 magnetic bead extractor (Qiagen, Hilden, Germany). PCRs, targeting the standard DNA barcode region COI, were carried out in 20 μl reaction volumes including 2 μl undiluted DNA template, 0.8 μl of each primer (10 pmol/μl; LCO1490-JJ: 5'-CHACWAAYCATAAAGATATYGG-3' and HCO2198-JJ: 5'-AWACTTCVGGRTGVCCAAARAATCA-3', (
Molecular data analysis
Data processing and sequence assembly were performed using the Geneious Pro v.7 (
In addition to the newly-generated DNA barcodes, we included all published DNA barcodes of Ponticola spp. deposited at BOLD and NCBI GenBank (Table
List of public CO1 sequences used for molecular analyses taken from BOLD and NCBI GenBank with information on Accession Number, drainage and country of origin.
Species |
Drainage |
Published by |
GenBank/BOLD Acc. N. |
Ponticola kessleri |
Elbe River (Germany) |
|
|
P. kessleri |
Elbe River (Germany) |
|
|
P. ratan |
Sea of Azov (Ukraine) |
|
|
P. cephalargoides |
Dniester River (Ukraine) |
|
|
P. rhodioni |
Vostochnyy Dagomys River (Russia) |
|
|
P. eurycephalus |
Odessa Bay (Ukraine) |
|
|
P. syrman |
Caspian Sea, Kiashahr beach (Iran) |
|
|
P. syrman |
Caspian Sea, Babolsar beach (Iran) |
|
|
P. gorlap |
Volga River (Russia) |
|
|
P. gorlap |
Caspian Sea (Azerbaijan) |
|
|
P. constructor |
Galitsga River, Black Sea basin (Georgia) |
|
|
P. constructor |
Kintrishi River, Black Sea basin (Georgia) |
|
|
P. cyrius |
Kura River (Georgia) |
|
|
P. cyrius |
Aragvi River (Georgia) |
|
|
P. iranicus |
Caspian Sea, Siah Darvishan River (Iran) |
|
|
P. iranicus |
Caspian Sea, Siah Darvishan River (Iran) |
|
|
P. patimari |
Caspian Sea, Chalous (Iran) |
|
|
Neogobius fluviatilis |
Rioni River, Black Sea basin (Georgia) |
|
|
Proterorhinus sp. |
Kintrishi River, Black Sea basin (Georgia) |
|
Subsequently, we evaluated sequence divergence and relationships between Ponticola spp, based on uncorrected p-distance. A Neighbour-Joining tree based on K2P (Kimura 2-parameter model) distances with 1000 bootstrap replicates was constructed to visualise the phylogenetic relationships amongst specimens (Fig.
Phylogenetic relationships are presented by the Neighbour-Joining tree, based on the mitochondrial COI barcode region using the Kimura 2 Parameter (K2P) distance model with other default parameters provided by Mega 11 software. Numbers near nodes indicate bootstrap support values from 1000 replicates. The analyses involved 25 COI nucleotide sequences of 14 goby species from the Black, Azov and Caspian Sea Basins.
Morphological examinations
All measurements were made using a digital caliper with a precision of 0.1 mm. We used a character set commonly used for the study of the Caucasian gobies (
Morphometric characters (ranges, means and standard deviations) of type specimens of Ponticola alasanicus sp. n.
Holotype + Paratypes (n = 5) |
|||
Holotype | Paratypes | ||
Character in mm |
Range |
Mean±SD |
|
Total body length |
73.5 |
52.0-73.5 |
65.7±7.86 |
Standard body length |
61.0 |
42.0-61.0 |
54.6±7.23 |
Number of anal fin branched rays |
12.0 |
10.5-12.5 |
11.7±0.81 |
Number of the second dorsal fin branched rays |
16.0 |
15.0-16.0 |
15.5±0.32 |
In percent of SL |
|||
Maximum body depth |
23.8 |
21.6-24.6 |
23.1± 1.22 |
Least depth of caudal peduncle |
12.9 |
12.0-14.3 |
13.04±0.76 |
Predorsal distance |
36.2 |
35.6-39.3 |
36.82±1.36 |
Length of the second dorsal fin base |
32.9 |
29.4-33.3 |
32.38±1.50 |
Height of the second dorsal fin |
14.4 |
11.8-14.4 |
13.04±1.02 |
Pre-anal distance |
57.4 |
56.7-60.8 |
58.44±1.71 |
Length of anal fin base |
24.6 |
21.6-24.6 |
22.82±1.19 |
Length of pectoral fin |
27.5 |
22.5-27.5 |
24.78±1.86 |
Length of ventral disc |
19.7 |
16.7-19.7 |
17.96±1.09 |
Caudal peduncle length |
18.0 |
17.1-19.0 |
18±0.64 |
Width of caudal peduncle at the anal fin |
6.6 |
6.6-8.5 |
7.6±0.67 |
Minimum width of caudal peduncle |
4.1 |
3.9-4.9 |
4.38±0.40 |
Head length |
29.5 |
27.1-32.1 |
29.28±1.66 |
In percent of HL |
|||
Horizontal diameter of eye |
22.2 |
22.2-25.6 |
23.24±1.25 |
Pre-orbital distance |
28.3 |
28.3-31.2 |
29.7±0.94 |
Postorbital distance |
60.6 |
55.6-60.6 |
58.3±2.12 |
Interorbital distance |
16.7 |
14.8-17.5 |
16.56±0.93 |
Width of upper lip |
45.0 |
44.1-48.1 |
45.66±1.52 |
Head depth at nape |
50.0 |
43.3-53.1 |
47.92±3.62 |
Head width |
75.0 |
66.7-81.2 |
74.54±4.72 |
Comparative materials: Ponticola syrman: ISU - SCCBO149-22 – 1007278, 168 mm SL, 205 mm TL, 1, Georgia: Caspian Sea Basin, Jandari Lake, Kvemo Kartli Region, N 41.438641 E 45.208572.
Ponticola cyrius: ISU - HIDPcy1, 54-99 mm SL, 65-122 mm TL, 5, Georgia: Caspian Sea Basin, Kvabliani River, Samtskhe-Javakheti Region, N 41.656865 E 42.776685.
ISU - HIDPcy10, 41-105 mm SL, 51-126 mm TL, 5, Georgia: Caspian Sea Basin, Kura River, Samtskhe-Javakheti Region, N 41.322334 E 43.229994.
ISU - HIDPcy13, 74 mm SL, 91 mm TL, 1, Georgia: Caspian Sea Basin, Aragvi River, Mtskheta-Mtianeti Region, N 42.035527 E 44.749659.
Ponticola constructor: ISU – HIDPco2, 47-77 mm SL, 57.5-92 mm TL, 6, Georgia: Black Sea Basin, Tskaltsitela River, Imereti Region, N 42.269336 E 42.741677.
ISU - HIDPco8, 46-69 mm SL, 56.5-85 mm TL, 3, Georgia: Black Sea Basin, Sulori River, Imereti Region, N 42.081774 E 42.522275.
ISU - HIDPco11, 40-88.5 mm SL, 46-104.5 mm TL, 3, Georgia: Black Sea Basin, Charnali River, Adjara Region, N 41.582625, E 41.625455.
Abbreviations used: TL, total length; SL, standard length; HL, lateral head length.
Collection codes: ISU – HIDPcy2, Ilia State University – Hydrobiology and Ichthyology Department.
In total, we obtained mitochondrial cytochrome oxidase subunit I (CO1) sequences from five specimens of Ponticola alasanicus sp. n. collected in the Tsitsmatiant Psha stream (right tributary of the Alazani River). For molecular analysis, we downloaded COI sequences of P. cyrius, P. constructor, P. syrman, P. gorlap, P. iranicus, P. patimari, P. kessleri, P. ratan, P. rhodioni, P. cephalargoides and P. eurycephalus (Table
Estimates of evolutionary divergence (%) over sequence pairs between Ponticola species distributed in the south-western Caspian and Georgian Black Sea Basins. Analyses were conducted using the Kimura 2-parameter model.
Species |
N |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
5 |
6 |
7 |
P. syrman |
1 |
|||||||
P. alasanicus sp. n. |
2 |
3.52 |
||||||
P. constructor |
3 |
7.22 |
8.25 |
|||||
P. cyrius |
4 |
7.86 |
8.47 |
4.96 |
||||
P. gorlap |
5 |
7.01 |
8.03 |
6.78 |
6.58 |
|||
P. iranicus |
6 |
1.89 |
3.59 |
7.74 |
8.17 |
7.63 |
||
P. patimari |
7 |
2.94 |
4.77 |
7.84 |
8.27 |
7.41 |
1.95 |
In the following, we provide a morphological description of the new Ponticola species.
Holotype: ISU - SCCBO130-22 – 1007251; Male, 73.5 mm TL, 61.0 mm SL; Georgia, Kakheti Region, Western Caspian Sea Basin, Tsitsmatiant Psha, right tributary of the Alazani River, near the Telavi-Eniseli connecting bridge, N41.988808, E45.577726; (collecting date: 11-Aug-2020).
Paratypes: ISU - SCCBO122-22 – 1007242, ISU - SCCBO131-22 – 1007252, ISU - SCCBO132- 22 – 1007253, ISU - SCCBO133-22 – 1007254, 52.0 – 71.0 mm TL, 42.0 – 59.0 mm SL, same data as holotype.
Additional materials used in morphological analyses: ISU - HIDPcy2, male, 71.0 mm TL, 58.5 mm SL; ISU – HIDPal2, female, 45.0 mm TL, 38.0 mm SL; ISU – HIDPal2, female, 69.0 mm TL, 57.0 mm SL; ISU – HIDPal2, female, 63.0 mm TL, 52 mm SL; HID – Pal2, male, 74.0 mm TL, 59.0 mm SL, same data as holotype/paratypes. Remark: these specimens were captured during resampling in 26-Dec-2020 and 30-May-2022 in the same location.
Description: D1 VI, D2 I / 16½, A I / 12½, l.l. 53. Body laterally compressed, gradually tapering from head to tail; minimum body depth almost 1.4 times less than caudal peduncle length; lateral parts of the body covered by ctenoid scales; first and second dorsal fins almost touching with their bases; second dorsal fin of uniform height; head large, depressed, wider than deep, its length approaches almost 3.4th its SL; nape scaled completely; cycloid scales cover upper part of opercle, cheeks noticeably swollen; snout longer than eye; eye diameter 4.5 times its HL; lower jaw slightly protruding; upper lip is uniform; pelvic disc elongated, not concave but flat, its length about 1.6 times less than ventro-anal distance, not reaching anus; pectoral fins reach base of first dorsal branched ray; caudal fin rounded.
The colouration of the preserved holotype yellowish-grey with dark brown and black blotches on the body (Fig.
Extended description based on all type specimens: Overall meristic characteristics: D1 VI-VII, D2 I / 15½-16½, A I / 10 ½-12½; l.l. 48-55. All studied specimens have a relatively short body, laterally compressed at caudal peduncle, the maximum length (TL) was fixed as 73.5 mm in holotype; 15½-16½ branched dorsal rays; 10½-12½ branched anal rays; scales in lateral line series from 48 to 55; minimum body depth is 1.3–1.5 times its caudal peduncle length; head relatively large, depressed, wider than deep, its length 3.1-3.7 times its SL; head width slightly larger than depth at nape, interorbital distance short from 2.0 to 3.0 mm; lower jaw slightly protruded, upper and low jaws same length; lips almost uniform, upper lip slightly swollen; pelvic disc short, elongated and flat, not reaching anus. In our samples, the largest specimen was a male with 59.0 mm SL and 74.0 mm TL. Sexual dimorphism is not pronounced, except that males are slightly longer than females.
Colouration: Live specimens have yellowish-grey colour with dark brown and black blotches on the body (Fig.
Head lateral-line system in Ponticola alasanicus sp. n. is similar to the other known species from the genus Ponticola (Fig.
D1 – VI, D2 I / 15½-16½, A I / 10½ – 12½; nape scaled completely, scales cycloid and ctenoid, cycloid scales covering upper part of opercle; lateral line system with sub-orbital row d continuous; predorsal area is linearly concave in middle; first dorsal fin with oblique black stripe between first two or three rays, the tip of the first 3-4 rays is transparent white; species has one large dark spot at the base of the pectoral fin; ventral disc has oval/elongated shape, short, not reaching anus.
Ponticola alasanicus sp. n. is distinguished from other species of the genus Ponticola entering freshwater habitats in the Caspian Sea Basin by the following characters:
It can be distinguished from P. syrman by fewer scales in mid-lateral series (48-55 vs. 57-67+2-3); relatively short body (maximum size 73.5 mm TL vs. 220 mm TL); cycloid scales on the nape (vs. ctenoid scales); the ventral disc is slightly shorter (16.7 -19.7 vs. 19.0-20.0% SL) and shorter pre-anal distance (56.7-60.8 vs. 61.3-64.4% SL); P. alasanicus sp. n. does not have transverse infraorbital papillae rows below longitudinal hyomandibular row b (vs. P. syrman has three rows).
Ponticola alasanicus sp. n. is distinguished from P. iranicus by relatively small body-size (42.0-61.0 mm SL vs. 65.0-83.0 mm SL); fewer scales in lateral series (48-55 vs. 55-60); pectoral fin reaching to second dorsal fin (vs. not reaching); minimum body depth almost 1.4 times less than caudal peduncle length (vs. 1.5-1.9 times in P. iranicus); interorbital distance particularly large from 1.3 to 1.5 mm in eye diameter compared to 0.3-0.8 mm in P. iranicus; absence of transverse infraorbital papillae rows bellow longitudinal hyomandibular row b (vs. P. iranicus has two rows: 5i and 6i).
Ponticola alasanicus sp. n. differs from P. patimari by a ventral disc that is noticeably shorter (16.7-19.7 vs. 20.2-26.0% SL), not reaching anus (vs. reaching in some specimens of P. patimari); additionally, there are seven transverse rows in P. alasanicus sp. n. comapred to six transverse rows in P. patimari).
Ponticola alasanicus sp. n. is also distinguished from the recently described P. hircaniaensis Zarei, Esmaeili, Kovačić, Schliewen & Abbasi, 2022 from the southern Caspian Sea Basin by a lower number of scales in the mid-lateral series (48-55 vs. 52-59) and a relatively short head depth at nape (43.3-53.1 vs. 70.9-81.0%).
Ponticola alasanicus sp. n. is distinguished from P. gorlap by having a longer maximum body depth (21.6-24.6 vs. 15.0-18.1% SL); a longer least depth of caudal peduncle (12.0-14.3 vs. 7.8-9.4% SL); cycloid scales on the nape and predorsal area (vs. ctenoid scales in P. gorlap); less scales in mid-lateral series (48-55 vs. 68-72 + 3-4); interorbital distance large (1.3-1.5 times vs. 0.8-0.9 times in eye diameter) and noticeably small body length (vs. TL in P. gorlap is almost three times larger).
Ponticola alasanicus sp. n. differs from P. cyrius by having an elongated and flattened ventral disc (vs. round and concave ventral disc); anterior membrane of ventral disc with shallow, slightly excised lobes (vs. deeply cut and angular in P. cyrius); P. alasanicus sp. n. has longer least depth of caudal peduncle (12.0-14.3 vs. 9.4-10.0% SL); shorter head width (66.7-81.2 vs. 81.4-100.0%); predorsal area with dark brown and black colouration (vs. marbled).
Ponticola alasanicus sp. n. is distinguished from all other Ponticola species (e.g. P. constructor, P. rhodioni, P. rizensis and P. turani) occurring in the Caucasian Black Sea Basin by following characters: P. alasanicus has fewer branched rays in dorsal fin 15½-16½ vs. 16½-19½ in P. constructor and P. rhodioni and 17½-19½ in P. turani and P. rizensis, respectively. P. alasanicus is also easily distinguished from the aforementioned gobies by noticeably short body (maximum reported SL = 61 mm) and elongated, short and flat-shaped ventral disc (vs. round and concave, with relatively long size ventral disc).
The species is named after the Alazani River.
Ponticola alasanicus sp. n. is endemic to the Alazani River Basin and currently known from the type locality (Tsitsmatiant Psha) and also from the small swamps near Shakriani (N42.001151 E45.600603) and Mshvidobiani (N41.76147 E46.130432) villages. Most likely inhabiting similar tributaries and habitats of the aforementioned river basin.
The new species inhabits small to medium-sized rivers called “Psha” (which means clear, cold water in Georgian and which can be used for drinking) with sand and plant substrate (Fig.
The new species has a small range (i.e. less than 20 km2) and is known only from the restricted area of the Alazani River Basin. The surrounding area of the known occurrences is within agricultural land where extensive use of pesticides and fertilisers is common. In addition, water intake from the river and illegal fishing are frequent (personal observation). Thus, we assume strong anthropogenic impacts on the habitat. Currently, the population trend is unknown. However, due to its extremly small range and high anthropogenic pressure, the conservation status of Ponticola alasanicus sp. n. can be regarded as vulnerable (
Inhabits lowland rivers and swampy habitats with sand and plant bottom. Often found near submerged trees and roots. Feeds on aquatic invertebrates. Spawns in May-June.
Research on the diversity of freshwater fishes of the South Caucasus Region and particularly in Georgia has been done with more or less intensity in past years. Recent molecular-genetic studies (
We would like to thank Levan Ninua, a researcher at Ilia State University who provided us with the coordinates of Tsitsmatiant Psha stream and helped us during the fieldwork. Genetic study was conducted under the ongoing project - Caucasus Barcode of Life (CaBOL - https://ggbc.eu/). Collecting permits were kindly provided by the Ministry of Environmental Protection and Agriculture of Georgia.
GE, BJ and LM developed the conception and design of the study, collected material and analysed data. LM supported the research logistics. GE and LM drafted manuscript. All authors participated in revising the article and contributed with intellectual content. All authors gave final approval of the submitted version.