Biodiversity Data Journal :
Research Article
|
Corresponding author: Rumyana Kostova (rkostova@biofac.uni-sofia.bg)
Academic editor: Lech Karpiński
Received: 30 Nov 2023 | Accepted: 02 Feb 2024 | Published: 05 Feb 2024
© 2024 Rumyana Kostova, Simeon Borissov, Aneliya Bobeva, Rostislav Bekchiev
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Kostova R, Borissov S, Bobeva A, Bekchiev R (2024) At a crossroads: Genetic lineages and dispersal routes of Morimus asper (Sulzer, 1776) s.l. (Coleoptera, Cerambycidae) in Bulgaria. Biodiversity Data Journal 12: e116619. https://doi.org/10.3897/BDJ.12.e116619
|
The present study fills a knowledge gap in the distribution and genetic variation of Morimus populations in the Balkans, by studiyng the representatives of the genus in Bulgaria – M. asper funereus Mulsant, 1862, M. verecundus bulgaricus Danilevsky, 2016 and M. orientalis Reitter, 1894. Additional information is provided for Albania and northern Greece. The mitochondrial cytochrome C oxidase subunit I (COI) marker and the nuclear internal transcribed spacer 2 (ITS2) were used for the genetic analyses. Three of the previously-defined mitochondrial lineages (Lb/HgA, L2 and L3) were detected in Bulgaria, as well as a new lineage (Str) from the Strandzha Mountains (south-eastern Bulgaria). A total of 24 distinct haplotypes, 20 of them in Bulgaria, were found. Bulgarian populations of Morimus demonstrated relatively high nucleotide diversity. The L3 COI lineage was confirmed as the most diverse and frequent in the Balkans. The L3 lineage is dominant in most of Bulgaria, but was not identified in the easternmost parts near the Black Sea coast, where the L2 and Str lineages were found. New data highlighted two dispersal routes of the L2 mitochondrial lineage on the Balkan Peninsula: 1) northwards along the Black Sea coast and 2) westwards, across the Balkans where only disjunct populations remain. North-western Bulgaria seems to be the eastern limit of the basal lineage Lb/HgA distribution. Our results show high levels of genetic exchange between most of the mitochondrially defined lineages, yet some of the easternmost populations probably remained isolated for comparatively longer periods.
longhorned beetles, Lamiinae, COI, ITS2, genetic diversity, Balkans
The members of the genus Morimus Brullé, 1832 are saproxylic longhorned beetles, widespread in central, southern and eastern Europe and in some regions of western Asia. They inhabit mostly old deciduous forests and possess a limited dispersal ability as they are flightless (
According to the latest publication by
Despite imperfections, due to different evolutionary processes that could bring discordance between gene and species trees (
The present study aims to extend the knowledge on the phylogenetic lineages distribution and genetic diversity of M. asper s.l. by extensive sampling in Bulgaria and neighbouring countries and to outline some routes of dispersal out of Pleistocene refugia that have remained undiscussed.
Sampling, molecular procedures and data preparation
Material was collected between 2019 and 2022 from Bulgaria, Albania and Greece (northern part). Sampling was targeted to cover populations of M. asper funereus, M. verecundus bulgaricus (type locality) and M. orientalis (Strandzha Mts.) (Fig.
Chromatograms were processed with CodonCode Aligner v.8.0.2 (CodonCode, Dedham, MA, USA). The obtained COI and ITS2 sequences were submitted to GenBank under accession numbers OR827907- OR827968 and OR844461- OR844487, respectively. Our own data were compiled with DNA sequences from previous studies (
Molecular phylogeny and demographic analyses
The mitochondrial phylogenetic analysis was based on the COI fragment and the newly-obtained 62 sequences were compiled with the published data — 54 sequences (
The best substitution models (for each coding position of COI and for ITS2 as a single partition) were estimated with PartitionFinder ver. 2.1.1 (
Nucleotide diversity, Tajima’s D (
Distribution of genetic diversity in the eastern Balkans
- COI gene
The final length of the COI fragment was 756 bp. A total of 62 new Morimus asper s.l. COI sequences were obtained from Bulgaria, northern Greece and Albania. These represented 24 distinct haplotypes (Suppl. material
Distribution of the COI lineages of Morimus asper s.l. in the Balkans and neighbouring parts of Turkey (including data by
- ITS gene
Overall, 27 new sequences from the nuclear 5.8S-ITS2 partial fragment were obtained in this study. The final length of the fragment was 373 bp, including gaps. Our own DNA sequences were aligned with those from
Phylogeny and population dynamics
The final length of the COI fragment used for phylogeny was 756 bp, from which 166 variable and 76 parsimony informative sites were obtained. The BI tree obtained in this study does not significantly contradict the previously-published phylogenies of
Nucleotide diversity and neutrality tests for L2 and L3 COI lineages including our own and published data (
Lineage |
Samples |
Haplotypes |
S |
Nucleotide diversity |
Tajima's D |
Significance of Tajima's D (p) |
CI (99%) of D H0: SNM |
D' |
F' |
Fu’s Fs |
L3 |
68 |
29 |
31 |
0.00389 |
-2.3355* |
< 0.001 | -1.955÷2.677 |
-3.4095 |
-3.6073 |
-45.984 |
L2 |
11 |
9 |
14 |
0.00551 |
-0.91732 |
> 0.10 | -1.889÷2.032 |
-1.1067 |
-1.1877 |
-5.556 |
L3 Bulgaria |
45 |
12 |
13 |
0.00351 |
-1.62679 |
> 0.10 | -2.043÷2.329 |
-1.9921 |
-2.1570 |
-12.165 |
Bulgaria all lineages |
54 |
20 |
49 |
0.01891 |
-0.09968 |
> 0.10 | -2.048÷2.144 |
0.3837 |
0.2783 |
-9.570 |
TCS network of the mitochondrial COI haplotypes of all samples. The original signatures of the haplotypes from
Morimus asper s.l. lineages in the eastern Balkans
Our study extends the knowledge on the distribution of mitochondrial lineages of M. asper in the eastern Balkans, covering most of the territory of Bulgaria, a part of northern Greece and northern Albania (Munella Mt.). New data demonstrates the presence of four mitochondrial lineages of Morimus asper s.l. in Bulgaria. Three of these were already defined by
The sample from the type locality of M. verecundus bulgaricus belongs to the L2 COI lineage and is identical with a haplotype already reported from Serbia by
The three individuals found in Strandzha Mts. have three mitochondrial haplotypes, similar to each other, but equally distant from the rest. These formed a clade sister to L3 on the COI phylogenetic tree (Suppl. material
Our results, as well the previous study by Solano et al. (2013), showed intense exchange gene flow between the different populations and genetic lineages of Morimus sp. and it is very likely that both M. verecundus and M. orientalis are subspecies of M. asper as
Dispersal routes
This study does not provide sufficient data for testing hypotheses about population structure, gene flow or confidently locating glacial refugia of M. asper. However, extensive sampling in the eastern Balkans (Bulgaria and northern Greece) bridges a significant knowledge gap regarding the distribution of genetic lineages, reaching the northern Black Sea coast to the east, thus highlighting some dispersal routes. In Bulgaria, the L3 lineage clearly dominates (Fig.
Prior to this study, the highest diversity of the L2 lineage was mainly reported from Turkey, with isolated haplotypes in Croatia (
All this is in line with a previously discussed scenario based on the association of Morimus with beech forests (
The newly-proposed Str lineage is more intriguing, as it is sister to L3, according to our phylogeny (Suppl. material
Conservation considerations
The taxonomic status of saproxylic beetles of the genus Morimus in Europe remains unclear and is highly debated with regard to their conservation and the inclusion of individual taxa in the Habitats Directive (
We thank all colleagues who contributed to the sample collection from Bulgaria and Albania. Thanks also to Ognyan Sivilov (Sofia University) for the Morimus verecundus bulgaricus image. We are also grateful to the anonymous reviewer, the subject editor Lech Karpiński (Museum and Institute of Zoology, Polish Academy of Sciences) and Paolo Audisio (Sapienza University of Rome) for their thoughtful suggestions that significantly improved this manuscript.
The material was collected under permit № 773/13.02.2019 for exceptions under the Biodiversity Act and for collection of protected beetle species from the Ministry of Environment and Water of the Republic of Bulgaria to the team associated with the National Museum of Natural History-BAS.
The research was supported by the project: “Cybertaxonomic approach to phylogenetic studies of model invertebrate genera (Invertebrata, Arachnida, Insecta) clarifying the problems of origin, formation and conservation of the Invertebrate Fauna of the Balkan Peninsula”. Grant KP-06-Н21/1-17.12.2018 National Science Fund.
Contains information about voucher specimens, localities, coordinates, COI and ITS2 accession numbers at GenBank, COI haplotypes (obtained from this study are noted as “Bal”), COI lineages and nuclear ITS2 comparison with previous studies (Solano et al. 2013; Gojković et al. 2022).
Bayesian inference tree using all available COI sequences (Solano et al. 2013, Gojković et al. 2022 and present data)
Bayesian inference tree using all available ITS2 sequences (Solano et al. 2013, Gojković et al. 2022 and present data)