|
Biodiversity Data Journal :
Research Article
|
|
Corresponding author: Gorky Ríos-Alvear (gork_dan@hotmail.com)
Academic editor: Ricardo Moratelli
Received: 19 Sep 2024 | Accepted: 11 Nov 2024 | Published: 20 Nov 2024
© 2024 Elias Viteri-Basso, Juan Reyes Puig, Carolina Reyes-Puig, Gorky Ríos-Alvear
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Viteri-Basso E, Reyes Puig J, Reyes-Puig C, Ríos-Alvear G (2024) Shadows in the forest: Uncovering unusual colouration records in mammals from the Ecuadorian Tropical Andes. Biodiversity Data Journal 12: e137463. https://doi.org/10.3897/BDJ.12.e137463
|
|
Variations in colouration patterns have been reported in numerous wildlife species, particularly birds. However, the increased use of camera traps for wildlife monitoring has enabled the detection of elusive species and phenotypic variations that might otherwise go undetected. Here, we compiled records of unusual colouration patterns in terrestrial mammals, documented through camera-trap studies over a 12-year period in the Llanganates-Sangay Connectivity Corridor, in the Tropical Andes of Ecuador. We identified colour variations in seven species of terrestrial mammals, including disorders, such as melanism, white spotting/ piebaldism, xanthocromism and progressive greying. Notably, we reported a high prevalence of melanism in wild populations of the clouded oncilla, along with observations on the species' activity patterns. Approximately half of the recorded clouded oncillas were melanistic. We detected significant differences in activty patterns between melanistic and non-melanistc clouded oncilla, with melanistic morphs showing a peak of activity between 3 a.m. and before dawn. The proportion of melanistic individuals suggests that melanism is widespread throughout the corridor. However, its impact on the species' fitness remains unclear.
colour anomalies, colouration, melanism, Leopardus spp., activity patterns, mammals, camera trap, CELS
Camera trapping is an effective and non-invasive technique for wildlife monitoring. It provides insights into the species behaviour, spatial distribution occurrence, predation and other ecological features which are difficult to observe directly (
Colour variation can be found in reptiles, birds, mammals, fish and even anurans. It is typically characterised by differences in the concentration of melanin and, although less common in mammals, by variations in the absorption of carotenoid pigments from their diet (
Gloger’s rule states that mammals in the Tropics are more likely to exhibit dark colourations and, thus, are prone to develop melanism (
Reporting unusual colouration in wildlife enhances our understanding of various aspects of their behaviour and biology. This includes describing the colour patterns of different species, clarifying species taxonomy, studying how colour affects survival rates and sexual selection and exploring its influence on predator-prey interactions, predatory success and the physiological implications of colour variation at both individual and population levels (
The Tropical Andes are considered a biodiversity hotspot (
We conducted the study in the eastern slopes of the Tropical Andes in Ecuador, in the Llanganates-Sangay Connectivity Corridor (CELS) (
We compiled camera-trap records from four studies carried out between 2011 and 2024 in CELS, as well as casual records shared by park rangers from the Sangay National Park, one museum record and one record of a melanistic deceased L. pardinoides that was run over. Studies were conducted with specific objectives, varying sampling efforts, spatial coverage and at different elevation ranges (Table
|
Source |
Year |
N° of sampling stations |
Sampling effort (trap/nights) |
N° of records of unusual colouration patterns |
|
|
2011–2012 |
10 |
1100 |
1 |
|
|
2019–2021 |
30 |
2532 |
1 |
|
This study (as part of Ríos-Alvear et al., unpublished data) |
2022–2024 |
62 |
21475 |
53 |
| This study: two casual encounters with melanistic Leopardus pardinoides (one dead and one run over) | 2023–2024 | - | - | 2 |
Due to the fact that most of our records were obtained from camera traps, which are subject to variations in image quality and resolution, we categorised the unusual colouration into five main categories. Four of them were phenotypically identified following
Criteria for identifying unusal colouration following the phenotypic identification of
Activity patterns have been defined as “the temporal structure of physical activity and sedentary behaviour [movement behaviours] accumulated over a specified time period during the waking hours” (
We analysed the activity patterns of species with the most independent records showing unusual colouration, specifically the clouded oncilla (Leopardus pardinoides) and margay (L. wiedii), which co-occur in the study area. We extracted the total independent records of non-melanistic individuals and those exhibiting melanistic colouration. The activity patterns of the non-melanistic and melanistic independent records were analysed with the package 'Activity' (
We compiled a total of 57 unusual colouration records encompassing seven different species: black agouti (Dasyprocta fuliginosa), tayra (Eira barbara), clouded oncilla (Leopardus pardinoides), margay (Leopardus wiedii), brown-nosed coati (Nasua nasua), western mountain coati (Nasua olivacea) and southern tamandua (Tamandua tetradactyla). Fifty-one of these were records of melanistic felids (Leopardus spp.). We documented only one independent record of a melanistic margay (Fig.
Proportion of independent records of individuals with unusual colouration compared to those with common colouration for each species (based on the count of independent records reported for each species in this article). Red colouration represents the independent camera-trap records with unusual colouration.
We recorded both melanistic and non-melanistic clouded oncillas at nearly 30% of our sampling locations within CELS. Notably, melanistic individuals were documented at 44% of the sampling sites across the species' distribution range. Interestingly, in 15% of our sampling locations, only melanistic clouded oncillas were observed (Fig.
We documented unusual colouration patterns in several terrestrial mammal species that, to our knowledge, have not been previously reported in the study area (Figs
Records of unusual colouration in terrestrial mammal species. A. Brown-nosed coati displaying the typical colouration pattern (Nasua nasua); B-C. Brown-nosed coatis exhibiting progressive greying in the flank, head and part of the legs; D. Western mountain coati (Nasua olivacea) exhibiting white spotting/piebaldism on the snout and part of the head, including the right eye; E. Xanthochromism in Southern tamandua (Tamandua tetradactyla).
Records of unusual colouration in terrestrial mammal species from CELS. A. Black agouti exhibiting white spotting/ piebaldism in the lower back; B. Tayra with a white spot/piebaldistic mark in the back of its right shoulder; C. Melanistic clouded oncilla active at the daytime; D. Melanistic clouded oncilla with visible dark rosettes at the flank.
Both Leopardus species are primarily nocturnal, although the clouded oncilla shows a slight increase in activity during the day compared to the margay (Fig.
Activity patterns of clouded oncilla and margay from CELS. A. Activity patterns of clouded oncilla (blue line) and margay (green dashed line) according to the total of records. Shaded in grey is the overlapping of activity patterns by hours; B. Activity patterns of melanistic (black line) and typically colouration records (red dashed line) of clouded oncilla; C. Activity patterns of melanistic records of clouded oncilla (black line) and typically colouration records of margay (green dashed line); D. Activity patterns of independent records with typically colouration only, clouded oncilla (red line) and margay (green dashed line).
Regarding activity levels between data-sets, we detected no significant differences between the clouded oncilla and margay (W = 1.872, p = 0.171), between melanistic and typically coloured clouded oncilla (W = 1.435, p = 0.230), between melanistic clouded oncilla and margay (W = 0.003, p = 0.954) or between typically coloured individuals of both species (W = 1.337, p = 0.247). On the other hand, activity pattern distributions showed significant differences between melanistic and non-melanistic clouded oncilla with a medium level of overlap (Δ = 0.74, 95% CI = 0.62 - 0.88, p = 0.04, Fig.
We include standout records of melanism in Leopardus species, with a significant proportion of daytime activity in camera trap records of melanistic individuals in comparison to non-melanistic ones. We also include proportions of all individual species records in comparison to unusual records per species (Fig.
The increasing prevalence of unusual colouration in mammalian populations raises intriguing questions about the underlying causes and potential implications for wild species. Historically, records of albinism, melanism and other pigmentation disorders have been geographically localised, often tied to specific genetic pools or environmental conditions (
Camera traps are a low-invasive method for monitoring wildlife, allowing the detection of elusive species and types of behaviour that are difficult to observe using traditional sampling methods (
The lack of pigmentation in wild mammals is generally considered a disadvantage, as it impacts the individual's camouflage, making it more visible to both predators and prey, therefore reducing its chances of successfully evading predators and hunting effectively (
Coat colour polymorphism in felids has been extensively studied (
Several hypotheses about melanism and its high frequency in wild felids are related to environmental variables such as humidity and temperature. It has been proposed that more humid environments improve thermoregulatory efficiency, as melanin pigments are better fixed, leading to a higher frequency of melanistic individuals in ecosystems with dense vegetation and high humidity (
The Llanganates-Sangay Connectivity Corridor hosts a rich diversity of ecosystems, spanning a wide elevation range (700–3812 m) (
Our study contributes to the growing database on colouration patterns and their rates of occurrence in terrestrial mammals. However, it also raises intriguing questions about the mechanisms driving the prevalence of unusual colouration patterns and their effects on wild populations. For example, we observed similar proportions of melanistic and non-melanistic clouded oncillas on both sides of the corridor. This suggests that colour variations are widespread across the study area and may confer a survival advantage (
We acknowledge the valuable participation and commitment of local inhabitants and conservationists from CELS during the various fieldwork campaigns conducted for this study. In particular, we extend our thanks to the EcoMinga Foundation, Finca Palmonte, Sumak Kawsay in Situ, Merazonia Wildlife Refuge, Bosque Protector Guamag, Reserva Natural Privada Leito, Chalwayaku, Fauna de la Amazonía, Biopark, Existe and Waska Amazonía. We are especially grateful to Jorge Brito and Rebecca Zug for their comments and assistance in the taxonomic identification of some camera trap records. We thank the park rangers of Sangay National Park for sharing their observations of melanistic individuals, especially Christian Paul Clavijo Romero, Luis Fernando Cajilema Rivera and Alfredo Zuña Cajilema. We thank Maria Cristina Ríos and Héctor Cadena for sharing the record of the road-killed melanistic clouded oncilla from Sangay National Park. We appreciate the reviewers' valuable suggestions, which have greatly enhanced the quality of the manuscript. The authors thank the institutions that made this research possible. JPRP and GRA thank WWF and EcoMinga Foundation. CRP thanks Universidad San Francisco de Quito USFQ, Museo de Zoología & Laboratorio de Zoología Terrestre and Instituto iBIOTROP for supporting this research. CRP work is supported by COCIBA grants (HUBI ID: 12267).
Conceptualisation: Gorky Ríos Alvear (GRA), Juan Pablo Reyes Puig (JPRP) and Carolina Reyes Puig (CRP) developed the initial concept and study design.
Data Collection: GRA, JPRP and CRP were responsible for data collection.
Review of camera-trap records: GRA, Elías Viteri Basso (EVB), JPRP and CRP contributed in the camera-trap records identification.
Data Analysis: CRP conducted the analysis of activity patterns.
Manuscript Writing: GRA, CRP, EVB and JPRP contributed to the manuscript's writing.
Review and Approval: All authors (EVB, JPRP, CRP and GRA) reviewed and approved the final version of the manuscript.