Biodiversity Data Journal :
Taxonomy & Inventories
|
Corresponding author: Ui Wook Hwang (uwhwang@knu.ac.kr), Joong-Ki Park (jkpark@ewha.ac.kr)
Academic editor: Andrew Davinack
Received: 15 Oct 2024 | Accepted: 10 Feb 2025 | Published: 18 Feb 2025
© 2025 Yukyung Kim, Jina Park, Ui Wook Hwang, Joong-Ki Park
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Kim Y, Park J, Hwang UW, Park J-K (2025) Taxonomic review of Korean Siphonaria species (Mollusca, Gastropoda, Siphonariidae). Biodiversity Data Journal 13: e139388. https://doi.org/10.3897/BDJ.13.e139388
|
|
Many molluscan species exhibit a high degree of shell morphological plasticity in their shape (including sculptures), size and colour patterns, which can vary significantly depending on environmental conditions. These shell morphological variations make it challenging to differentiate species, based on morphology alone, often resulting in various taxonomic errors, such as misidentifications, overlooking cryptic species diversity or a plethora of nominal species. The genus Siphonaria constitutes a significant component of the macrobenthic invertebrate fauna in intertidal habitats across temperate to tropical regions. Given the limited attention to shell variation in previous taxonomic studies on the Korean Siphonaria species, the extensive range of ecophenotypic shell variations documented in this group raises questions about the taxonomic validity of previously reported Siphonaria species in Korea.
The present study provides a comprehensive taxonomic review of Korean Siphonaria species using a combination of shell morphology, radula structure and phylogenetic analysis of the mtDNA cox1 sequences. This integrative analysis confirmed the validity of S. acmaeoides, S. japonica and S. sirius in Korea, highlighting differences in shell and siphonal groove morphology amongst these species. Detailed descriptions of shell and radula characteristics, along with mtDNA cox1 sequences as DNA barcodes, are also provided, which are very useful for the accurate identification of Siphonaria species. Unlike these three Siphonaria species, the taxonomic validity of the four other species (S. coreensis, S. javanica, S. laciniosa and S. rucuana) previously reported from Korean waters is questionable, given their documented geographic distribution ranges and the potential misidentification of shell variants in Korean malacofaunal studies.
Panpulmonata, Korean Siphonaria, taxonomic review, shell morphology, radula, mtDNA cox1
The genus Siphonaria G. B. Sowerby I, 1823, also known as the ‘false limpet’ genus, is a marine panpulmonate group consisting of 106 species worldwide (
Siphonaria species exhibit remarkedly high ecophenotypic shell variation, leading to many taxonomic complications such as species misidentification and the potential for unrecognised cryptic species (
In this study, we re-examined the taxonomic validity of six Siphonaria species previously reported in Korea by conducting a comprehensive comparison of morphological characters described in previous records against the original descriptions, based on an in-depth analysis of shell and radula morphologies, combined with mtDNA cox1 sequence data. Based on the results of this taxonomic re-assessment, we provide detailed morphological descriptions of the shell morphology and radula microstructures of three Siphonaria species (S. acmaeoides, S. japonica and S. sirius) confirmed to occur along the Korean coast using scanning electron microscopy (SEM), as well as a phylogenetic analysis of the mtDNA cox1 sequences.
Specimens were collected from intertidal rocky shores in Korea (Fig.
Map showing the sampling localities for Korean Siphonaria examined in this study. 1 Daejin-ri, Hyeonnae-myeon, Goseong-gun, Gangwon-do; 2 Jeonjin-ri, Ganghyeon-myeon, Yangyang-gun, Gangwon-do; 3 Namae-ri, Hyeonnam-myeon, Yangyang-gun, Gangwon-do; 4 Namyang-ri, Seo-myeon, Ulleung-gun, Gyeongsangbuk-do; 5 Dokdo-ri, Ulleung-eup, Ulleung-gun, Gyeongsangbuk-do; 6 Jukbyeon-ri, Jukbyeon-myeon, Uljin-gun, Gyeongsangbuk-do; 7 Guryongpo-eup, Nam-gu, Pohang-si, Gyeongsangbuk-do; 8 Gujora-ri, Irun-myeo, Geoje-si, Gyeongsangnam-do; 9 Mendehaean-gil, Tongyeong-si, Gyeongsangnam-do; 10 Gahak-ri, Jisan-myeon, Jindo-gun, Jeollanam-do; 11 Seopo-ri, Deokjeok-myeon, Ongjin-gun, Incheon; 12 Jeju-si Samyang 1(il)-dong, Jeju-do; 13 Seongsan-eup, Seogwipo-si, Jeju-do; 14 Andeok-myeon, Seogwipo-si, Jeju-do. Circles with multiple colours represent localities where the corresponding species were found together.
For sequencing of the mtDNA cox1 gene fragments, genomic DNA was extracted from foot tissue by using a DNeasy Blood and Tissue kit (QIAGEN, Germany) following the manufacturer’s protocol. The partial mitochondrial cox1 gene sequence was amplified by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) using the primer pair LCO1490 and HCO2198 (
The newly-determined cox1 sequences of S. acmaeoides, S. japonica and S. sirius were deposited in GenBank (accession numbers in Table
Sampling localities and GenBank accession numbers of mtDNA cox1 sequences of Siphonaria species used for molecular analysis.
Species |
Locality |
GenBank accession nos. |
References |
S. acmaeoides_01 |
Guryongpo-eup, Nam-gu, Pohang-si, Gyeongsangbuk-do |
This study |
|
S. acmaeoides_02 |
Sagye-ro, Andeok-myeon, Seogwipo-si, Jeju-do |
This study |
|
S. acmaeoides_03 |
Sagye-ro, Andeok-myeon, Seogwipo-si, Jeju-do |
This study |
|
S. acmaeoides_04 |
Hyeongjehaean-ro, Andeok-myeon, Seogwipo-si, Jeju-do |
This study |
|
S. acmaeoides_05 |
Sagye-ro, Andeok-myeon, Seogwipo-si, Jeju-do |
This study |
|
S. atra |
China |
Unpublished |
|
S. japonica |
Japan |
|
|
S. japonica |
Taiwan |
|
|
S. japonica |
Taiwan |
|
|
S. japonica |
Taiwan |
|
|
S. japonica |
Japan |
|
|
S. japonica_01 |
Onpyeong-ro, Seongsan-eup, Seogwipo-si, Jeju-do |
This study |
|
S. japonica_02 |
Onpyeong-ro, Seongsan-eup, Seogwipo-si, Jeju-do |
This study |
|
S. japonica_03 |
Daejin-ri, Hyeonnae-myeon, Goseong-gun, Gangwon-do |
This study |
|
S. javanica |
Singapore |
|
|
S. laciniosa |
Japan |
|
|
S. laciniosa |
Japan |
|
|
S. laciniosa |
Japan |
|
|
S. sirius |
Japan |
|
|
S. sirius |
Japan |
|
|
S. sirius_01 |
Mendehaean-gil, Tongyeong-si, Gyeongsangnam-do |
This study |
|
S. sirius_02 |
Nambu-myeon, Geoje-si, Gyeongsangnam-do |
This study |
|
S. sirius_03 |
Mendehaean-gil, Tongyeong-si, Gyeongsangnam-do |
This study |
|
S. subatra |
Japan |
|
|
S. subatra |
Japan |
|
|
S. subatra |
Japan |
|
|
S. subatra |
Japan |
|
|
S. zelandica |
Australia |
|
|
S. zelandica |
Australia |
|
|
S. zelandica |
Australia |
|
|
S. zelandica |
Australia |
|
|
T. afer |
- |
|
|
T. reticulatus |
- |
|
Siphonaria acmaeoides Pilsbry, 1894:
Siphonaria (Patellopsis) acmaeoides:
Siphonaria zebra:
Planesiphon acmaeoides:
Siphonaria (Mouretus) acmaeoides:
Siphonaria (Planesiphon) acmaeoides:
Measurements: Shell length [SL] 11.32–17.58 mm, Shell width [SW] 9.42–14.87 mm, Shell height [SH] 2.63–6.73 mm.
Shell (Fig.
Shell morphology of three Korean Siphonaria species. Red arrowhead: S. acmeoides; Yellow arrowhead: S. japonica, Blue arrowhead: S. sirius. Scale bars = 5 mm.
Radula (Fig.
Radula morphology of three Korean Siphonaria species. Abbreviations: m, mesocone; ec, ectocone. Scale bars = 20 µm.
Korea, Japan and Taiwan.
Type locality: Japan; Boshiu island (Boso Peninsula).
Habitat: On rocky substrate in high intertidal zones, typically in shallow pools (Fig.
The Korean S. acmaeoides corresponds well with
Uncorrected p-distance (%) for the mtDNA cox1 sequences amongst Siphonaria species. The species which include newly-determined species in this study are denoted by asterisks (*).
S. japonica* |
S. zelandica |
S. acmaeoides* |
S. javanica |
S. laciniosa |
S. sirius* |
S. atra |
S. subatra |
|
S. japonica* |
0.16–1.75 |
|||||||
S. zelandica |
28.89–29.84 |
0.16–1.90 |
||||||
S. acmaeoides* |
29.37–30.95 |
5.71–6.51 |
0.16–3.33 |
|||||
S. javanica |
29.52–30.32 |
29.05–30.00 |
29.37–30.16 |
- |
||||
S. laciniosa |
29.05–30.14 |
28.57–29.52 |
28.57–29.68 |
15.56–16.03 |
0.16–0.79 |
|||
S. sirius* |
30.79–31.90 |
28.25–29.68 |
27.94–29.21 |
30.63–30.79 |
29.52–30.48 |
0.16–0.79 |
||
S. atra |
31.27–31.90 |
27.78–28.25 |
28.25–28.82 |
27.46 |
27.14–27.30 |
22.38–22.86 |
- |
|
S. subatra |
31.90–33.81 |
29.68–30.63 |
29.37–30.63 |
29.68–30.79 |
29.21–30.48 |
25.24–25.87 |
15.87–16.51 |
2.06–3.33 |
Phylogenetic relationships amongst some selected NWP Siphonaria species inferred from the Maximum Likelihood method using the mtDNA cox1 sequences. The bootstrap supporting values (≥ 50%) are indicated on the branches. Asterisks (*) represents the mtDNA cox 1 sequences determined in this study.
Patella japonica
? Siphonaria radiata:
? Siphonria radians:
Siphonaria cochleariformis:
Siphonaria japonica:
Siphonaria alterniplicata:
Siphonaria (Sacculosiphonaria) japonica:
Sacculosiphonaria japonica:
Siphonaria (Mastosiphon) sirius:
Siphonaria acmaeoides:
Siphonaria (Planesiphon) acmaeoides:
Siphonaria japonica tall form:
Measurements: SL 10.5–15.45 mm, SW 7.5–12.24 mm, SH 2.81–4.7 mm.
Shell (Fig.
Radula (Fig.
Korea, China, Japan and Taiwan.
Type locality: Japan.
Habitat: On rocky substrate in low to high intertidal zones (Fig.
S. japonica is commonly found in intertidal zones along the Korean coast, often occurring alongside S. acmaeoides and S. sirius (Fig.
Siphonaria (Siphonaria) javanica:
Siphonaria javanica:
Japan (Okinawa island), Malaysia, Palau, Indonesia and northeast Australia.
Type locality: Indonesia; Java Island.
This species was initially included by
Siphonaria laciniosa:
Siphonaria (Siphonaria) laciniosa:
Siphonaria (Mestosiphon) laciniosa:
Persian Gulf, Red Sea, Samaoan Islands, Tonga, Fiji (
Type locality: India.
Siphonaria rucuana:
Siphonaria (Siphonaria) rucuana:
Japan (Okinawa Island).
Type locality: Japan; Ryukyu island (Okinawa Island).
Siphonaria sirius
Siphonaria (Siphonaria) sirius:
Siphonaria (Mestosiphon) sirius:
Anthosiphonaria sirius:
Siphonaria laciniosa forma sirius:
Siphonaria laciniosa:
Siphonaria subatra:
Siphonacmea oblongata:
Siphonaria (Anthosiphonaria) sirius:
Measurements: SL 11.23–19.63 mm, SW 9.09–15.62 mm, SH 2.87–4.93 mm.
Shell (Fig.
Radula (Fig.
Korea, China, Japan, Philippines, Singapore, Indonesia (Sumatra Island) and Vietnam.
Type locality: Japan; Sagami, Kashiurazaki, Boshiu (Boso Peninsula).
Habitat: On rocky substrate in middle to low intertidal zones (Fig.
This species is clearly distinguished from other Korean sympatric species (S. acmaeoides and S. japonica) by its flat shell, remarkably extended white radial ribs, siphonal groove with a single radial rib and pale-coloured inner centre (Fig.
Previously, a total of seven Siphonaria species have been sparsely reported in Korea, based solely on external shell morphologies that has often resulted in taxonomic complications, including misidentification of species due to their remarkably high ecophenotypic variations. From a comprehensive analysis of shell morphology, radula structure and molecular analysis of mtDNA cox1 sequences in this study, three species (S. acmaeoides, S. japonica and S. sirius) have been confirmed to occur in Korea. The three Korean Siphonaria species commonly share the presence of secondary ribs and often exhibit an eroded apex as they grow (Fig.
Our phylogenetic analysis using mtDNA cox1 sequences of these three Korean Siphonaria species and some other congeneric species confirmed their morphology-based species identification (Fig.
In conclusion, many molluscan species, including Siphonaria species, exhibit a high degree of morphological plasticity in shell shape (including sculptures), size and colour, which can vary significantly depending on environmental conditions. These variations in shell morphology make it challenging to differentiate species based on morphology alone, often resulting in various taxonomic errors, such as misidentifications, overlooking cryptic species diversity or a plethora of nominal species. Our taxonomic review incorporating both morphological and molecular data revealed that Korean Siphonaria species also display a wide range of shell morphological variations within species (e.g. shell colour, number of radial ribs and the slope of the anterior and posterior shell). Moreover, in many cases — including those observed in the present study — some species exhibiting a wide range of shell morphological variations are often found co-occurring in the same intertidal habitats. A comprehensive analysis of integrated morphological and molecular data, obtained through extensive taxon sampling along the Korean coastline can provide better resolution to address taxonomic ambiguities amongst Siphonaria species.
This work was supported by a grant from the National Institute of Biological Resources (NIBR), funded by the Ministry of Environment (MOE) of the Republic of Korea (NIBR202231206) and the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF) grant funded by the Korea government (MSIT) (2020R1A2C2005393) to JKP and by Global-Learning & Academic research institution for Masters'·PhD students and Postdocs (LAMP) Program of the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF) grant funded by the Ministry of Education (No. RS-2023-00301914) to UWH.