Biodiversity Data Journal : Taxonomy & Inventories
PDF
Taxonomy & Inventories
Taxonomic review of Korean Siphonaria species (Mollusca, Gastropoda, Siphonariidae)
expand article infoYukyung Kim, Jina Park, Ui Wook Hwang§, Joong-Ki Park
‡ Division of EcoScience, Ewha Womans University, Seoul, Republic of Korea
§ Department of Biology Education, Teachers College and Institute for Phylogenomics and Evolution, Kyungpook National University, Daegu, Republic of Korea
Open Access

Abstract

Background

Many molluscan species exhibit a high degree of shell morphological plasticity in their shape (including sculptures), size and colour patterns, which can vary significantly depending on environmental conditions. These shell morphological variations make it challenging to differentiate species, based on morphology alone, often resulting in various taxonomic errors, such as misidentifications, overlooking cryptic species diversity or a plethora of nominal species. The genus Siphonaria constitutes a significant component of the macrobenthic invertebrate fauna in intertidal habitats across temperate to tropical regions. Given the limited attention to shell variation in previous taxonomic studies on the Korean Siphonaria species, the extensive range of ecophenotypic shell variations documented in this group raises questions about the taxonomic validity of previously reported Siphonaria species in Korea.

New information

The present study provides a comprehensive taxonomic review of Korean Siphonaria species using a combination of shell morphology, radula structure and phylogenetic analysis of the mtDNA cox1 sequences. This integrative analysis confirmed the validity of S. acmaeoides, S. japonica and S. sirius in Korea, highlighting differences in shell and siphonal groove morphology amongst these species. Detailed descriptions of shell and radula characteristics, along with mtDNA cox1 sequences as DNA barcodes, are also provided, which are very useful for the accurate identification of Siphonaria species. Unlike these three Siphonaria species, the taxonomic validity of the four other species (S. coreensis, S. javanica, S. laciniosa and S. rucuana) previously reported from Korean waters is questionable, given their documented geographic distribution ranges and the potential misidentification of shell variants in Korean malacofaunal studies.

Keywords

Panpulmonata, Korean Siphonaria, taxonomic review, shell morphology, radula, mtDNA cox1

Introduction

The genus Siphonaria G. B. Sowerby I, 1823, also known as the ‘false limpet’ genus, is a marine panpulmonate group consisting of 106 species worldwide (MolluscaBase eds 2024). Siphonaria species constitute a significant component of the macrobenthic community in intertidal/subtidal habitats across temperate to tropical regions, but some are found in cold temperature environments, such as sub-Antarctic shores (Vermeij 1971, Hodgson 1999, Dayrat et al. 2014, González‐Wevar et al. 2018). They are typically inhabit intertidal rocky shores, but are occasionally found at the bottom of rocks or amongst seagrass in the subtidal zone (Collin 2000, Toyohara et al. 2001, Dayrat et al. 2014, Okutani 2000, Okutani 2017). Taxonomically, Sowerby (1823) first introduced the genus name Siphonaria with the type species S. sipho Sowerby, 1823 (now considered as a junior synonym of S. javanica (Lamark, 1819), distinguishing it from the ‘true limpet’ genera Patella Linnaeus, 1758 and Emarginula Lamarck, 1801 by its posteriorly curved apex and a prominent siphonal groove on the lateral side. The siphonal groove allows animals to perform air-breathing through the mantle cavity, while the secondary gill supports aquatic respiration. These characteristics distinguish them from Patellogastropoda (i.e. true limpets), which also have a similar conical or cap-like shell, but lack the siphonal groove, relying solely on gills for their respiration.

Siphonaria species exhibit remarkedly high ecophenotypic shell variation, leading to many taxonomic complications such as species misidentification and the potential for unrecognised cryptic species (White and Dayrat 2012, Dayrat et al. 2014, De Coito 2021). To date, seven species have been recorded in Korea (National Institute of Biological Resources 2023, Jenkins and Köhler 2024): S. acmaeoides Pilsbry, 1894, S. coreensis A. Adams and Reeve, 1848, S. japonica (Donovan, 1824), S. javanica (Lamarck, 1819), S. laciniosa (Linnaeus, 1758), S. sirius Pilsbry 1894, and S. rucuana Pilsbry, 1904. Of these, S. coreensis is designated as a "taxon inquirendum" in the World Register of Marine Species (MolluscaBase eds 2025), reflecting the view of several authorities who have suggested that it may represent a misidentification of S. atra Quoy & Gaimard, 1833 (Lischke 1871, Shikama 1964, Cernohorsky 1972, Jenkins and Köhler 2024). Furthermore, its occurrence in Korea, as well as northern Pacific Region, has not been substantiated since its initial report. In addition, most previous Korean Siphonaria records relied primarily on species checklists or taxonomic illustrations, lacking detailed descriptions of diagnostic characters and overlooking individual shell variation in their species identification. Given the limited attention to shell variation in previous studies, the extensive ecophenotypic morphological plasticity observed in this group raises questions regarding the taxonomic validity of previously reported Korean Siphonaria species. Insufficient and/or erroneous taxonomic information has continued to pose challenges not only in taxonomy, but also in other scientific fields that rely on accurate species identification.

In this study, we re-examined the taxonomic validity of six Siphonaria species previously reported in Korea by conducting a comprehensive comparison of morphological characters described in previous records against the original descriptions, based on an in-depth analysis of shell and radula morphologies, combined with mtDNA cox1 sequence data. Based on the results of this taxonomic re-assessment, we provide detailed morphological descriptions of the shell morphology and radula microstructures of three Siphonaria species (S. acmaeoides, S. japonica and S. sirius) confirmed to occur along the Korean coast using scanning electron microscopy (SEM), as well as a phylogenetic analysis of the mtDNA cox1 sequences.

Materials and methods

Specimens were collected from intertidal rocky shores in Korea (Fig. 1) and preserved in 95% ethanol solution. For species identification and morphological descriptions, shells were observed using a stereoscopic microscope (Leica M205C, Wetzlar, Germany) and radula characters were examined using a scanning electron microscope (SEM). To prepare the radula for SEM examination, the radula sac was extracted from the buccal mass and residual tissue was dissolved in a mixture of 180 μl ATL buffer and 20 μl Proteinase K at 56°C for about 1 hour. Then the radula was rinsed with distilled water and ethanol, mounted on nickel tape attached to an SEM stub, air-dried and coated with platinum. Radula images were captured using an SEM (Zeiss Ultra Plus, Germany) and a FE-SEM (Jeol JSM-7800F, Japan). The examined specimens are deposited at the National Institute of Biological Resources (NIBR) in Incheon, Korea and the Animal Phylogenomics Laboratory at Ewha Womans University, Seoul, Korea.

Figure 1.  

Map showing the sampling localities for Korean Siphonaria examined in this study. 1 Daejin-ri, Hyeonnae-myeon, Goseong-gun, Gangwon-do; 2 Jeonjin-ri, Ganghyeon-myeon, Yangyang-gun, Gangwon-do; 3 Namae-ri, Hyeonnam-myeon, Yangyang-gun, Gangwon-do; 4 Namyang-ri, Seo-myeon, Ulleung-gun, Gyeongsangbuk-do; 5 Dokdo-ri, Ulleung-eup, Ulleung-gun, Gyeongsangbuk-do; 6 Jukbyeon-ri, Jukbyeon-myeon, Uljin-gun, Gyeongsangbuk-do; 7 Guryongpo-eup, Nam-gu, Pohang-si, Gyeongsangbuk-do; 8 Gujora-ri, Irun-myeo, Geoje-si, Gyeongsangnam-do; 9 Mendehaean-gil, Tongyeong-si, Gyeongsangnam-do; 10 Gahak-ri, Jisan-myeon, Jindo-gun, Jeollanam-do; 11 Seopo-ri, Deokjeok-myeon, Ongjin-gun, Incheon; 12 Jeju-si Samyang 1(il)-dong, Jeju-do; 13 Seongsan-eup, Seogwipo-si, Jeju-do; 14 Andeok-myeon, Seogwipo-si, Jeju-do. Circles with multiple colours represent localities where the corresponding species were found together.

For sequencing of the mtDNA cox1 gene fragments, genomic DNA was extracted from foot tissue by using a DNeasy Blood and Tissue kit (QIAGEN, Germany) following the manufacturer’s protocol. The partial mitochondrial cox1 gene sequence was amplified by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) using the primer pair LCO1490 and HCO2198 (Folmer et al. 1994). Amplifications were performed in a 50 μl total volume, containing 3 μl of template DNA, 35.75 μl of distilled water, 5 μl of 10x Ex Taq buffer, 1 μl of each primer, 4 μl of dNTP and 0.25 μl of TaKaRa Ex Taq DNA polymerase (TaKaRa Bio, Japan) under the following conditions: an initial denaturation at 95℃ for 5 min, 40 cycles of denaturation at 94℃ for 40 s, annealing at 48℃ for 1 min, elongation at 72℃ for 1 min and a final extension at 72℃ for 10 min. The PCR-amplified target fragment was purified using a Qiaquick gel extraction kit (Qiagen Valencia, USA), sequenced using an ABI PRISM 3730xl DNA analyser (Applied Biosystems, USA) and analysed using Geneious Prime v. 2022.2.2 (Biomaters, Auckland, New Zealand).

The newly-determined cox1 sequences of S. acmaeoides, S. japonica and S. sirius were deposited in GenBank (accession numbers in Table 1). The cox1 sequences from the three Korean Siphonaria species and the homologous gene sequences from NCBI database (Table 1) were used for phylogenetic analysis with two outgroup species; Trimusculus afer (Gmelin, 1791) and T. reticulatus (G. B. Sowerby I, 1835). The sequences were aligned using the default settings of MUSCLE (Edgar 2004) in the Geneious software and trimmed to a length of 630 bp. MEGA X was used to calculate genetic distances within and between species, applying uncorrected p-distance (Collins et al. 2012; Srivathsan and Meier 2012). To select the best-fit nucleotide substitution model, ModelFinder (Kalyaanamoorthy et al. 2017), implemented in IQ-TREE v.1.6.12. Nguyen et al. (2015) was applied with the corrected Akaike Information Criterion (AICc). Phylogenetic analysis was performed using Maximum Likelihood (ML) estimation with IQ-TREE software, with the K3Pu+F+I+G4 substitution model and 1,000 standard bootstrap pseudoreplicates (Felsenstein 1985) to assess branch support values.

Table 1.

Sampling localities and GenBank accession numbers of mtDNA cox1 sequences of Siphonaria species used for molecular analysis.

Species

Locality

GenBank accession nos.

References

S. acmaeoides_01

Guryongpo-eup, Nam-gu, Pohang-si, Gyeongsangbuk-do

PQ422946

This study

S. acmaeoides_02

Sagye-ro, Andeok-myeon, Seogwipo-si, Jeju-do

PQ422947

This study

S. acmaeoides_03

Sagye-ro, Andeok-myeon, Seogwipo-si, Jeju-do

PQ422948

This study

S. acmaeoides_04

Hyeongjehaean-ro, Andeok-myeon, Seogwipo-si, Jeju-do

PQ422949

This study

S. acmaeoides_05

Sagye-ro, Andeok-myeon, Seogwipo-si, Jeju-do

PQ422950

This study

S. atra

China

OQ735434

Unpublished

S. japonica

Japan

KF000756

Dayrat et al. (2014)

S. japonica

Taiwan

KF000759

Dayrat et al. (2014)
S. japonica

Taiwan

KF000760

Dayrat et al. (2014)
S. japonica

Taiwan

KF000762

Dayrat et al. (2014)
S. japonica

Japan

KF000835

Dayrat et al. (2014)
S. japonica_01

Onpyeong-ro, Seongsan-eup, Seogwipo-si, Jeju-do

PQ422951

This study

S. japonica_02

Onpyeong-ro, Seongsan-eup, Seogwipo-si, Jeju-do

PQ422952

This study

S. japonica_03

Daejin-ri, Hyeonnae-myeon, Goseong-gun, Gangwon-do

PQ422953

This study

S. javanica

Singapore

KF690503

Ip et al. (2019)

S. laciniosa

Japan

KF000727

Dayrat et al. (2014)

S. laciniosa

Japan

KF000728

Dayrat et al. (2014)

S. laciniosa

Japan

KF000758

Dayrat et al. (2014)

S. sirius

Japan

KF000832

Dayrat et al. (2014)

S. sirius

Japan

KF000833

Dayrat et al. (2014)

S. sirius_01

Mendehaean-gil, Tongyeong-si, Gyeongsangnam-do

PQ422954

This study

S. sirius_02

Nambu-myeon, Geoje-si, Gyeongsangnam-do

PQ422955

This study

S. sirius_03

Mendehaean-gil, Tongyeong-si, Gyeongsangnam-do

PQ422956

This study

S. subatra

Japan

KF000743

Dayrat et al. (2014)

S. subatra

Japan

KF000754

Dayrat et al. (2014)

S. subatra

Japan

KF000755

Dayrat et al. (2014)

S. subatra

Japan

KF000757

Dayrat et al. (2014)

S. zelandica

Australia

JX680967

Colgan and Da Costa (2013)
S. zelandica

Australia

KF000725

Dayrat et al. (2014)

S. zelandica

Australia

KF000791

Dayrat et al. (2014)

S. zelandica

Australia

KF000793

Dayrat et al. (2014)

T. afer

-

EF489388

Klussmann-Kolb et al. (2008)

T. reticulatus

-

JN632509

White et al. (2011)

Taxon treatments

Siphonaria acmaeoides Pilsbry, 1894

Nomenclature

Siphonaria acmaeoides Pilsbry, 1894: Pilsbry 1894: 16; Pilsbry 1895: 6, pl. 6, figs. 19–22; Lee 1956: 79; Hirase 1941: 94, pl. 121, fig. 15; Kuroda and Habe 1952: 86 (cited from Jenkins and Köhler 2024); Azuma 1960: 62 (cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)); Baker 1964: 159 (cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)); Christiaens 1980b: 466; White and Dayrat 2012: 60 [checklist]; Jenkins and Köhler 2024: 114, 115, figs. 43A–D, M, N, 44A–C.

Siphonaria (Patellopsis) acmaeoides: Hubendick 1945: 70, fig. 19 (cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)); Hubendick 1946: 30, pl. 6, figs. 12–15; Habe and Kikuchi 1960: 64 (cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)); Kira 1962: 201, pl. 69, fig. 9a, b (misspelled as 'Patellops'; cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)).

Siphonaria zebra: Kuroda and Habe 1952: 86 (non Siphonaria zebra Reeve, 1856) (cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)).

Planesiphon acmaeoides: Kuroda et al. 1971: 484, pl. 64, fig. 8; Choe 1992: 749, pl. 126, fig. 224.

Siphonaria (Mouretus) acmaeoides: Christiaens 1980a: 79, 80.

Siphonaria (Planesiphon) acmaeoides: Inaba 1983: 149 (cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)); Je 1989: 29 [checklist]; Higo et al. 1999: 402, G4976 [checklist]; Okutani 2000: 815, pl. 405, fig. 7; Cheng et al. 2005: 8, fig. 1e–g; Noseworthy et al. 2007: 90 [checklist]; Okutani 2017: 1101, pl. 403, fig. 7.

Materials   Download as CSV 
  1. scientificName:
    Siphonaria acmaeoides
    ; kingdom:
    Animalia
    ; phylum:
    Mollusca
    ; class:
    Gastropoda
    ; order:
    Siphonariida
    ; family:
    Siphonariidae
    ; genus:
    Siphonaria
    ; specificEpithet:
    acmaeoides
    ; scientificNameAuthorship:
    Pilsbry, 1894
    ; country:
    Korea
    ; locality:
    Hyeongjehaean-ro, Andeok-myeon, Seogwipo-si, Jeju-do
    ; verbatimCoordinates:
    33°13'37.13"N 126°18'30.92"E
    ; eventDate:
    2012-01-07
    ; individualCount:
    1
    ; catalogNumber:
    NIBRIV0000307707
    ; occurrenceID:
    83FCD050-F70C-5128-B42F-DE6C1A9BA020
  2. scientificName:
    Siphonaria acmaeoides
    ; kingdom:
    Animalia
    ; phylum:
    Mollusca
    ; class:
    Gastropoda
    ; order:
    Siphonariida
    ; family:
    Siphonariidae
    ; genus:
    Siphonaria
    ; specificEpithet:
    acmaeoides
    ; scientificNameAuthorship:
    Pilsbry, 1894
    ; country:
    Korea
    ; locality:
    Sagye-ro, Andeok-myeon, Seogwipo-si, Jeju-do
    ; verbatimCoordinates:
    33°13'13.2"N 126°17'42.0"E
    ; eventDate:
    2022-04-21
    ; individualCount:
    3
    ; occurrenceID:
    D7664B8A-483D-5DD2-9933-CECE40648E65
  3. scientificName:
    Siphonaria acmaeoides
    ; kingdom:
    Animalia
    ; phylum:
    Mollusca
    ; class:
    Gastropoda
    ; order:
    Siphonariida
    ; family:
    Siphonariidae
    ; genus:
    Siphonaria
    ; specificEpithet:
    acmaeoides
    ; scientificNameAuthorship:
    Pilsbry, 1894
    ; country:
    Korea
    ; locality:
    Donghaean-ro, Guryongpo-eup, Nam-gu, Pohang-si, Gyeongsangbuk-do
    ; verbatimCoordinates:
    35°57'05.7"N 129°33'04.4"E
    ; eventDate:
    2023-07-23
    ; individualCount:
    3
    ; occurrenceID:
    A1D5EA8B-4851-5AD4-A0A1-2FCC3E1B0328
  4. scientificName:
    Siphonaria acmaeoides
    ; kingdom:
    Animalia
    ; phylum:
    Mollusca
    ; class:
    Gastropoda
    ; order:
    Siphonariida
    ; family:
    Siphonariidae
    ; genus:
    Siphonaria
    ; specificEpithet:
    acmaeoides
    ; scientificNameAuthorship:
    Pilsbry, 1894
    ; country:
    Korea
    ; locality:
    Irun-myeon, Geoje-si, Gyeongsangnam-do
    ; verbatimCoordinates:
    34°58'34.9"N 128°41'18.18"E
    ; eventDate:
    2023-04-19
    ; individualCount:
    1
    ; occurrenceID:
    84F9DDD5-5BD5-5645-8D86-F3D843A9ACD2

Description

Measurements: Shell length [SL] 11.32–17.58 mm, Shell width [SW] 9.42–14.87 mm, Shell height [SH] 2.63–6.73 mm.

Shell (Fig. 2a, b) solid, oval, small to medium in size (in examined specimens, SL 11.32–17.58 mm), medium-high in height (about 2/7 on its length). Exterior colour generally greyish-brown or yellowish-brown with dark brown irregular maculations. Shell surface with 14–17 wide, light-cream or white-coloured primary ribs, unevenly spaced, sometimes discontinuous from apex to outer shell margin in juvenile. Interspaces between primary ribs filled with 1–7 thin secondary ribs. Apex white, glossy, spiral in counterclockwise direction (Fig. 2bC), often eroded due to shell growth, positioned in posterior one-third of shell, biased towards left. Shell margin weakly undulated. Anterior slope slightly convex, posterior slope short, nearly straight. Siphonal groove indistinct on outer shell surface. Interior colour dark brown, reddish-brown, with light cream bands near margin, reddish-brown or pale at centre.

Figure 2.

Shell morphology of three Korean Siphonaria species. Red arrowhead: S. acmeoides; Yellow arrowhead: S. japonica, Blue arrowhead: S. sirius. Scale bars = 5 mm.

aA S. acmaeoides on rocky substrate of Korea, Jeju; B Dorsal, ventral and lateral view (left) of S. acmaeoides from Jeju.  
bC Apex of S. acmaeoides juvenile from Jeju; D Dorsal, ventral, and lateral view (left) of S. acmaeoides juvenile from Jeju.  
cE S. japonica on rocky substrate of Korea, Jeju; F Dorsal, ventral and lateral view (left) of S. japonica from Goseong.  
dG S. sirius on rocky substrate of Korea, Jeju; H Dorsal, ventral and lateral view of S. sirius from Geoje.  

Radula (Fig. 3a, b) dentition formulae 27:1:27 (in specimens measuring SL 16.23 mm, SW 11.88 mm, SH 4.80 mm). Each transverse row with narrow central rachidian tooth flanked by symmetrical half rows with lateral teeth, decreasing in size outwards. Rachidian tooth (Fig. 3a) short, approximately one-third length of lateral tooth, with sharply-pointed cusp. Innermost lateral teeth (first 7 lateral teeth), each tooth consisting of mesocone without ectocone; mesocone with bicuspid (Fig. 3a). Middle lateral teeth (following 5 lateral teeth), each tooth consisting of mesocone and ectocone; mesocone with bicuspid to blunt towards the outer margins; ectocone sharply pointed. Outermost lateral teeth (remaining 12 lateral teeth) consisting of endocone, ectocone and mesocone; mesocone subquadrate-shaped; endocone and ectocone short, sharply pointed (Fig. 3b).

Figure 3.

Radula morphology of three Korean Siphonaria species. Abbreviations: m, mesocone; ec, ectocone. Scale bars = 20 µm.

aS. acmaeoides - Details of rachidian teeth (arrowhead) and innermost lateral teeth.  
bS. acmaeoides - Details of outermost lateral teeth.  
cS. japonica - Details of rachidian teeth (arrowhead) and innermost lateral teeth.  
dS. japonica - Details of outermost lateral teeth.  
eS. sirius - Details of rachidian teeth (arrowhead) and innermost lateral teeth.  
fS. sirius - Details of outermost lateral teeth.  

Distribution

Korea, Japan and Taiwan.

Type locality: Japan; Boshiu island (Boso Peninsula).

Habitat: On rocky substrate in high intertidal zones, typically in shallow pools (Fig. 2aA).

Taxon discussion

The Korean S. acmaeoides corresponds well with Pilsbry (1894)'s original description. The external shell morphology is characterised by wide, low primary ribs with fine secondary ribs in the interspaces, a glossy spiral apex coiling counterclockwise and a weakly undulated shell margin. Christiaens (1980a) described a new subspecies, S. acmaeoides paulae Christiaens, 1980, from Hong Kong, distinguishing it by its finer, thinner, more elliptical, lighter-coloured shell. This subspecies was also noted to lack a marked central area and exhibit a more bulging siphon compared to S. acmaeoides reported from Japan. However, Jenkins and Köhler (2024) later synonymised S. a. paulae with the S. acmaeoides, citing the morphological similarity of the shell. Based on our examination of the Korean specimens (Fig. 2b), we did not observe the light-coloured shell characteristics described in S. a. paulae by Christiaens (1980a). Further morphological and molecular analyses for S. a. paulae sampled from Hong Kong are necessary to confirm the taxonomic validity of this subspecies. In addition, S. acmaeoides has repeatedly been noted for its similarity in shell and radula morphology to S. zelandica Quoy and Gaimard, 1833 which is distributed in Australia (Hubendick 1946, Dayrat et al. 2014, Jenkins and Köhler 2024). Both species share the following morphological characteristics: a homostrophic apex, broad primary ribs with fine secondary ribs and an innermost lateral tooth in the radula with a mesocone that lacks ectocone and endocone (Quoy and Gaimard 1833, Pilsbry 1894, Jenkins 1983, Jenkins and Köhler 2024). Hubendick (1946) reported the radula formula of S. acmaeoides as 26:1:26, noting the absence of an ectocone on the lateral teeth. In this study, we observed a similar pattern of radula characters, with a radula formula of 27:1:27, also lacking an ectocone on the lateral teeth. This can be generally included within the documented range of intraspecific variation for the genus Siphonaria (e.g. in S. lessonii Blaninville, 1827, the radula formula varies from 13:1:13 to 76:1:76; Hubendick (1946), Güller et al. (2016)). In shell morphology, S. acmaeoides is distinguished by having its less prominent, almost flat radial ribs and a more indistinct siphonal groove, whereas S. zelandica is characterised by relatively finer and dual radial ribs within the siphonal groove. In our phylogenetic tree, the two species form a sister clade with 95% bootstrap support (Fig. 4). The uncorrected p-distances between S. acmaeoides and S. zelandica range from 5.71 to 6.51%, while S. sirius, the next closest related species shows a significantly higher genetic divergence (27.94%) (Table 2). Thus, a taxonomic re-assessment of the two species is necessary to confirm their taxonomic validity.

Table 2.

Uncorrected p-distance (%) for the mtDNA cox1 sequences amongst Siphonaria species. The species which include newly-determined species in this study are denoted by asterisks (*).

S. japonica*

S. zelandica

S. acmaeoides*

S. javanica

S. laciniosa

S. sirius*

S. atra

S. subatra

S. japonica*

0.16–1.75

S. zelandica

28.89–29.84

0.16–1.90

S. acmaeoides*

29.37–30.95

5.71–6.51

0.16–3.33

S. javanica

29.52–30.32

29.05–30.00

29.37–30.16

-

S. laciniosa

29.05–30.14

28.57–29.52

28.57–29.68

15.56–16.03

0.16–0.79

S. sirius*

30.79–31.90

28.25–29.68

27.94–29.21

30.63–30.79

29.52–30.48

0.16–0.79

S. atra

31.27–31.90

27.78–28.25

28.25–28.82

27.46

27.14–27.30

22.38–22.86

-

S. subatra

31.90–33.81

29.68–30.63

29.37–30.63

29.68–30.79

29.21–30.48

25.24–25.87

15.87–16.51

2.06–3.33

Figure 4.  

Phylogenetic relationships amongst some selected NWP Siphonaria species inferred from the Maximum Likelihood method using the mtDNA cox1 sequences. The bootstrap supporting values (≥ 50%) are indicated on the branches. Asterisks (*) represents the mtDNA cox 1 sequences determined in this study.

Siphonaria japonica (Donovan, 1824)

Nomenclature

Patella japonica Donovan 1824: pl. 79; Kuroda et al. 1971: 483, pl. 64, fig. 7; White and Dayrat 2012: 64 [checklist].

? Siphonaria radiata: Adams and Reeve 1850: 69, pl. 13, fig. 2.

? Siphonria radians: Adams and Adams 1855: 271; Hubendick 1946: 43.

Siphonaria cochleariformis: Reeve 1856: pl. 6, fig. 28; Hubendick 1946: 43, pl. 2, figs. 33–35; Kuroda et al. 1971: 483, pl. 64, fig. 7.

Siphonaria japonica: Hanley 1858: 152 [checklist]; Pilsbry 1920: 141; Abe 1940: 59 (cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)); Hirase 1941: 94, pl. 121, fig. 12; Kuroda 1941: 137; Hubendick 1945: 27, fig. 34, 36, 39, 41 (cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)); Kuroda and Habe 1952: 86 (cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)); Lee 1956: 79; Kuroda 1960: 43 (cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)); Habe and Kikuchi 1960: 64 (cited from Jenkins and Köhler 2024); Shikama 1964: 6 (cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)); Berry 1977: 197, fig. 19 (cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)); Lee and Chao 2003: 35, pl. 6, fig. 173; Qi 2004: 198, pl. 108, fig. E; Dayrat et al. 2014: 266, fig. 3B; Jenkins and Köhler 2024: 31–34, figs. 13A–L, Q–S, 15B–E.

Siphonaria alterniplicata: Grabau and King 1928: 237, pl. 11, fig. 117; Hubendick 1946: 62; White and Dayrat 2012: 60 [checklist]; Coan et al. 2015: 221, fig. 38A, B.

Siphonaria (Sacculosiphonaria) japonica: Hubendick 1946: 42, pl. 2, figs. 29–32; Kira 1962: 201, pl. 69, fig. 8a, b (cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)); Habe 1971: 15, pl. 4, fig. 16 (cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)); Yoo 1976: 89, pl. 19, figs. 1–4; Christiaens 1980a: 79; Christiaens 1980b: 466, 467; Je 1989: 89 [checklist]; Fukuda et al. 1992: 76, pl. 23, fig. 360a, b (cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)); Kwon et al. 1993: 334, fig. 61-1; Okutani 2000: 815, pl. 405, fig. 6; Kwon 2001: 191, fig. 723; Hamamura 2004: 115; Min et al. 2004: 335, fig. 1056; Noseworthy et al. 2007: 90 [checklist]; Okutani 2017: 1101, pl. 403, fig. 6.

Sacculosiphonaria japonica: Kuroda et al. 1971: 483, pl. 64, fig. 7; Trew 1983: 9 (cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)); Choe 1992: 747, 748, pl. 125, fig. 222.

Siphonaria (Mastosiphon) sirius: Yoo 1976: 89, pl. 19, fig. 5 (non Siphonaria sirius Pilsbry 1894).

Siphonaria acmaeoides: Kwon et al. 1993: 335, fig. 61-3 (non-Siphonaria acmaeoides Pilsbry 1894).

Siphonaria (Planesiphon) acmaeoides: Kwon 2001: 191, fig. 724; Min et al. 2004: 337, fig. 1057 (non-Siphonaria acmaeoides in Pilsbry (1894)).

Siphonaria japonica tall form: Yokogawa et al. 2010: fig. 1A.

Materials   Download as CSV 
  1. scientificName:
    Siphonaria japonica
    ; kingdom:
    Animalia
    ; phylum:
    Mollusca
    ; class:
    Gastropoda
    ; order:
    Siphonariida
    ; family:
    Siphonariidae
    ; genus:
    Siphonaria
    ; specificEpithet:
    japonica
    ; scientificNameAuthorship:
    (Donovan, 1824)
    ; country:
    Korea
    ; locality:
    Namyang-ri, Seo-myeon, Ulleung-gun, Gyeongsangbuk-do
    ; verbatimCoordinates:
    37°27'34.5"N, 130°51'27.4"E
    ; eventDate:
    2011-11-13
    ; individualCount:
    20
    ; catalogNumber:
    NIBRIV0000894428–NIBRIV0000894447
    ; occurrenceID:
    8CB2FFA8-7177-5D58-9987-D944894409D8
  2. scientificName:
    Siphonaria japonica
    ; kingdom:
    Animalia
    ; phylum:
    Mollusca
    ; class:
    Gastropoda
    ; order:
    Siphonariida
    ; family:
    Siphonariidae
    ; genus:
    Siphonaria
    ; specificEpithet:
    japonica
    ; scientificNameAuthorship:
    (Donovan, 1824)
    ; country:
    Korea
    ; locality:
    Jeonjin-ri, Ganghyeon-myeon, Yangyang-gun, Gangwon-do
    ; verbatimCoordinates:
    38°07'31.5"N, 128°37'52.3"E
    ; eventDate:
    2014-04-09
    ; individualCount:
    10
    ; catalogNumber:
    NIBRIV0000894458–NIBRIV0000894467
    ; occurrenceID:
    E2FA26B9-DF79-5C3B-BAA0-2A7982854C38
  3. scientificName:
    Siphonaria japonica
    ; kingdom:
    Animalia
    ; phylum:
    Mollusca
    ; class:
    Gastropoda
    ; order:
    Siphonariida
    ; family:
    Siphonariidae
    ; genus:
    Siphonaria
    ; specificEpithet:
    japonica
    ; scientificNameAuthorship:
    (Donovan, 1824)
    ; country:
    Korea
    ; locality:
    Jukbyeon-ri, Jukbyeon-myeon, Uljin-gun, Gyeongsangbuk-do
    ; verbatimCoordinates:
    37°3'32.50"N, 129°25'43.92"E
    ; eventDate:
    2014-04-09
    ; individualCount:
    20
    ; catalogNumber:
    NIBRIV0000894468–NIBRIV0000894487
    ; occurrenceID:
    59D7504B-74E8-514D-BCCA-3C6F3557C300
  4. scientificName:
    Siphonaria japonica
    ; kingdom:
    Animalia
    ; phylum:
    Mollusca
    ; class:
    Gastropoda
    ; order:
    Siphonariida
    ; family:
    Siphonariidae
    ; genus:
    Siphonaria
    ; specificEpithet:
    japonica
    ; scientificNameAuthorship:
    (Donovan, 1824)
    ; country:
    Korea
    ; locality:
    Namae-ri, Hyeonnam-myeon, Yangyang-gun, Gangwon-do
    ; verbatimCoordinates:
    37°56'33.7"N, 128°47'17.8"E
    ; eventDate:
    2014-08-24
    ; individualCount:
    3
    ; catalogNumber:
    NIBRIV0000894448NIBRIV0000894450
    ; occurrenceID:
    8451E1F2-DB21-501A-A3C9-52209A958584
  5. scientificName:
    Siphonaria japonica
    ; kingdom:
    Animalia
    ; phylum:
    Mollusca
    ; class:
    Gastropoda
    ; order:
    Siphonariida
    ; family:
    Siphonariidae
    ; genus:
    Siphonaria
    ; specificEpithet:
    japonica
    ; scientificNameAuthorship:
    (Donovan, 1824)
    ; country:
    Korea
    ; locality:
    Samyang 1(il)-dong Jeju-si Jeju-do
    ; verbatimCoordinates:
    33°31'34.6"N, 126°35'09.0"E
    ; eventDate:
    2015-12-21
    ; individualCount:
    15
    ; catalogNumber:
    NIBRIV0000894548-NIBRIV0000894562
    ; occurrenceID:
    7E7E0FC6-5FF9-5A57-A3BD-6F006D828021
  6. scientificName:
    Siphonaria japonica
    ; kingdom:
    Animalia
    ; phylum:
    Mollusca
    ; class:
    Gastropoda
    ; order:
    Siphonariida
    ; family:
    Siphonariidae
    ; genus:
    Siphonaria
    ; specificEpithet:
    japonica
    ; scientificNameAuthorship:
    (Donovan, 1824)
    ; country:
    Korea
    ; locality:
    Namae-ri, Hyeonnam-myeon, Yangyang-gun, Gangwon-do
    ; verbatimCoordinates:
    37°56'33.7"N, 128°47'17.8"E
    ; eventDate:
    2016-03-02
    ; individualCount:
    7
    ; catalogNumber:
    NIBRIV0000894451-NIBRIV0000894457
    ; occurrenceID:
    CC219B8C-1E0B-5581-B327-D492B0178063
  7. scientificName:
    Siphonaria japonica
    ; kingdom:
    Animalia
    ; phylum:
    Mollusca
    ; class:
    Gastropoda
    ; order:
    Siphonariida
    ; family:
    Siphonariidae
    ; genus:
    Siphonaria
    ; specificEpithet:
    japonica
    ; scientificNameAuthorship:
    (Donovan, 1824)
    ; country:
    Korea
    ; locality:
    Dokdo-ri, Ulleung-eup, Ulleung-gun, Gyeongsangbuk-do
    ; verbatimCoordinates:
    37°14'20.12"N, 131°52'05.74"E
    ; eventDate:
    2016-06-22
    ; individualCount:
    17
    ; catalogNumber:
    NIBRIV0000894408-NIBRIV0000894424
    ; occurrenceID:
    2CD256A6-3489-5322-9FA4-8F75AF0BCF39
  8. scientificName:
    Siphonaria japonica
    ; kingdom:
    Animalia
    ; phylum:
    Mollusca
    ; class:
    Gastropoda
    ; order:
    Siphonariida
    ; family:
    Siphonariidae
    ; genus:
    Siphonaria
    ; specificEpithet:
    japonica
    ; scientificNameAuthorship:
    (Donovan, 1824)
    ; country:
    Korea
    ; locality:
    Gahak-ri, Jisan-myeon, Jindo-gun, Jeollanam-do
    ; verbatimCoordinates:
    34°25'48.1"N, 126°05'55.6"E
    ; eventDate:
    2016-07-08
    ; individualCount:
    20
    ; catalogNumber:
    NIBRIV0000894508-NIBRIV0000894527
    ; occurrenceID:
    0D774AF9-C5DA-5C87-B0AE-26873ED2A1F7
  9. scientificName:
    Siphonaria japonica
    ; kingdom:
    Animalia
    ; phylum:
    Mollusca
    ; class:
    Gastropoda
    ; order:
    Siphonariida
    ; family:
    Siphonariidae
    ; genus:
    Siphonaria
    ; specificEpithet:
    japonica
    ; scientificNameAuthorship:
    (Donovan, 1824)
    ; country:
    Korea
    ; locality:
    Ojo-ri, Seongsan-eup, Seogwipo-si, Jeju-do
    ; verbatimCoordinates:
    33°28'14.8"N, 126°55'21.9"E
    ; eventDate:
    2017-06-27
    ; individualCount:
    2
    ; catalogNumber:
    NIBRIV0000894563-NIBRIV0000894564
    ; occurrenceID:
    EE49E3D2-2BA0-5D88-8772-0303B4B71649
  10. scientificName:
    Siphonaria japonica
    ; kingdom:
    Animalia
    ; phylum:
    Mollusca
    ; class:
    Gastropoda
    ; order:
    Siphonariida
    ; family:
    Siphonariidae
    ; genus:
    Siphonaria
    ; specificEpithet:
    japonica
    ; scientificNameAuthorship:
    (Donovan, 1824)
    ; country:
    Korea
    ; locality:
    Hwasun-ri, Andeok-myeon, Seogwipo-si, Jeju-do
    ; verbatimCoordinates:
    33°14'20.7"N, 126°20'01.6"E
    ; eventDate:
    2017-06-28
    ; individualCount:
    3
    ; catalogNumber:
    NIBRIV0000894565-NIBRIV0000894567
    ; occurrenceID:
    0CBFE4F7-A55D-52DF-AAC8-16500149F3AD
  11. scientificName:
    Siphonaria japonica
    ; kingdom:
    Animalia
    ; phylum:
    Mollusca
    ; class:
    Gastropoda
    ; order:
    Siphonariida
    ; family:
    Siphonariidae
    ; genus:
    Siphonaria
    ; specificEpithet:
    japonica
    ; scientificNameAuthorship:
    (Donovan, 1824)
    ; country:
    Korea
    ; locality:
    Seopo-ri, Deokjeok-myeon, Ongjin-gun, Incheon
    ; verbatimCoordinates:
    37°13'03.16"N, 126°06'55.67"E
    ; eventDate:
    2018-04-17
    ; individualCount:
    20
    ; catalogNumber:
    NIBRIV0000894488-NIBRIV0000894507
    ; occurrenceID:
    BEF4F2B8-098D-5566-8920-C4545FAEE777
  12. scientificName:
    Siphonaria japonica
    ; kingdom:
    Animalia
    ; phylum:
    Mollusca
    ; class:
    Gastropoda
    ; order:
    Siphonariida
    ; family:
    Siphonariidae
    ; genus:
    Siphonaria
    ; specificEpithet:
    japonica
    ; scientificNameAuthorship:
    (Donovan, 1824)
    ; country:
    Korea
    ; locality:
    Gujora-ri, Irun-myeon, Geoje-si, Gyeongsangnam-do
    ; verbatimCoordinates:
    34°48'31.93"N, 128°41'25.97"E
    ; eventDate:
    2018-06-12
    ; individualCount:
    20
    ; catalogNumber:
    NIBRIV0000894528-NIBRIV0000894547
    ; occurrenceID:
    B872D531-A994-59F3-A5E9-E1FDD9EAB14F
  13. scientificName:
    Siphonaria japonica
    ; kingdom:
    Animalia
    ; phylum:
    Mollusca
    ; class:
    Gastropoda
    ; order:
    Siphonariida
    ; family:
    Siphonariidae
    ; genus:
    Siphonaria
    ; specificEpithet:
    japonica
    ; scientificNameAuthorship:
    (Donovan, 1824)
    ; country:
    Korea
    ; locality:
    Dokdo-ri, Ulleung-eup, Ulleung-gun, Gyeongsangbuk-do
    ; verbatimCoordinates:
    37°14'20.12"N, 131°52'05.74"E
    ; eventDate:
    2021-06-02
    ; individualCount:
    3
    ; catalogNumber:
    NIBRIV0000894425-NIBRIV0000894427
    ; occurrenceID:
    3B25F340-A40E-5225-BBC0-AC7D16CA5F33
  14. scientificName:
    Siphonaria japonica
    ; kingdom:
    Animalia
    ; phylum:
    Mollusca
    ; class:
    Gastropoda
    ; order:
    Siphonariida
    ; family:
    Siphonariidae
    ; genus:
    Siphonaria
    ; specificEpithet:
    japonica
    ; scientificNameAuthorship:
    (Donovan, 1824)
    ; country:
    Korea
    ; locality:
    Guryongpo-eup, Nam-gu, Pohang-si, Gyeongsangbuk-do
    ; verbatimCoordinates:
    35°57'11.5"N, 129°32'50.4"E
    ; eventDate:
    2023-07-12
    ; individualCount:
    1
    ; occurrenceID:
    FB198DA4-1645-5901-BDFA-506AE0CDD712
  15. scientificName:
    Siphonaria japonica
    ; kingdom:
    Animalia
    ; phylum:
    Mollusca
    ; class:
    Gastropoda
    ; order:
    Siphonariida
    ; family:
    Siphonariidae
    ; genus:
    Siphonaria
    ; specificEpithet:
    japonica
    ; scientificNameAuthorship:
    (Donovan, 1824)
    ; country:
    Korea
    ; locality:
    Daejin-ri, Hyeonnae-myeon, Goseong-gun, Gangwon-do
    ; verbatimCoordinates:
    38°29'57.1"N, 128°25'38.7"E
    ; eventDate:
    2024-03-20
    ; individualCount:
    1
    ; occurrenceID:
    1B68A9AE-75A2-505F-8F9E-E9AE8E3C17F9
  16. scientificName:
    Siphonaria japonica
    ; kingdom:
    Animalia
    ; phylum:
    Mollusca
    ; class:
    Gastropoda
    ; order:
    Siphonariida
    ; family:
    Siphonariidae
    ; genus:
    Siphonaria
    ; specificEpithet:
    japonica
    ; scientificNameAuthorship:
    (Donovan, 1824)
    ; country:
    Korea
    ; locality:
    Onpyeong-ro, Seongsan-eup, Seogwipo-si, Jeju-do
    ; verbatimCoordinates:
    33°24'03.7"N, 126°54'17.7"E
    ; eventDate:
    2024-07-28
    ; individualCount:
    3
    ; occurrenceID:
    C26236C2-BD2D-5ED5-94A0-A09287579017
  17. scientificName:
    Siphonaria japonica
    ; kingdom:
    Animalia
    ; phylum:
    Mollusca
    ; class:
    Gastropoda
    ; order:
    Siphonariida
    ; family:
    Siphonariidae
    ; genus:
    Siphonaria
    ; specificEpithet:
    japonica
    ; scientificNameAuthorship:
    (Donovan, 1824)
    ; country:
    Korea
    ; locality:
    Sagye-ro, Andeok-myeon, Seogwipo-si, Jeju-do
    ; verbatimCoordinates:
    33°13'13.2"N 126°17'42.0"E
    ; eventDate:
    2022-04-21
    ; individualCount:
    2
    ; occurrenceID:
    DE709C43-9BAD-5511-BB20-64DF8FE5144F

Description

Measurements: SL 10.5–15.45 mm, SW 7.5–12.24 mm, SH 2.81–4.7 mm.

Shell (Fig. 2c) thin, oval, small size (in examined specimens, SL 10.5–15.45 mm), medium-high in height (2/7 of its length). Exterior colour greyish-brown. Shell surface with 17–23 thin, yellowish white-coloured primary radial ribs. Interspaces between radial ribs sometimes with 1–2 secondary ribs. Apex eroded, located centrally in posterior one-third of shell. Shell margin weakly undulated. Anterior slope slightly convex, posterior slope shorter, nearly straight. Siphonal groove weakly prominent with two radial ribs on outer shell surface. Interior colour reddish-brown.

Radula (Fig. 3c, d) dentition formulae 29:1:29 (in specimens measuring SL 10.54 mm, SW 7.47 mm, SH 2.81 mm). Each transverse row with narrow central rachidian tooth flanked by symmetrical half rows with lateral teeth, decreasing in size outwards. Rachidian tooth (Fig. 3c) short, -approximately one-third length of lateral tooth, with sharply pointed cusp. Innermost lateral teeth (first 17 lateral teeth), each tooth consisting of mesocone and ectocone; mesocone with bicuspid or unicuspid (Fig. 3c); ectocone shorter, pointed. Outermost lateral teeth (remaining 12 lateral teeth) consisting of endocone, ectocone and mesocone; mesocone paddle-shaped, not angled; endocone and ectocone short, sharply pointed (Fig. 3d).

Distribution

Korea, China, Japan and Taiwan.

Type locality: Japan.

Habitat: On rocky substrate in low to high intertidal zones (Fig. 2cE).

Taxon discussion

Jenkins and Köhler (2024) designated a neotype for S. japonica due to the absence of the original type specimens and provided a detailed description of the shell morphology, reproductive system and morphological features of spermatophore. The shell morphology of the Korean S. japonica specimens match es well both by Donovan (1824)'s original description and the observations by Jenkins and Köhler (2024). Nevertheless, moderate variations in the number of ribs were observed in this study, with the number of primary ribs ranging from 17 to 23 and secondary ribs ranging from 1 to 2. These ranges differ from those reported by Jenkins and Köhler (2024), which included up to 20 primary ribs and 2 to 3 secondary ribs. In addition, Jenkins and Köhler (2024) considered the shell images of Figs. 1 and 4 of S. japonica described by Yoo (1976) to likely represent misidentification, without providing detailed information on their interpretation. Upon re-examination of the Figs. 1 and 4, we observed that the specimens show characteristics consistent with S. japonica, including 20–25 primary ribs with secondary rib interstices (though the exact number is ambiguous) and two primary ribs on the siphonal groove. Based on our integrated analyses of the morphology (including the number of radial ribs on the shell surface) and molecular sequence data, we have concluded that all the shell images in Yoo (1976), including Figs. 1 and 4, represent within the normal range of shell variations typically observed in S. japonica. In radula morphology, Hubendick (1946) provided a brief sketch of radula characters, based on only two specimens in his description of S. japonica. He provided a radula formula ranging from 32:1:32 to 40:1:40 and noted the presence of an ectocone on the innermost lateral teeth. Our examination of the Korean specimens revealed a radula formula of 29:1:29, which differs from those reported in Hubendick (1946), while the presence of an ectocone on the innermost lateral teeth was consistent with his findings. These observations suggest that the radula formula can vary within the same species.

S. japonica is commonly found in intertidal zones along the Korean coast, often occurring alongside S. acmaeoides and S. sirius (Fig. 2aA, Fig. 2dG). Their wide range of distribution and variations in shell morphology can lead to confusion in identification, resulting in past misidentifications in Korean illustrations as S. sirius (Yoo 1976) and S. acmaeoides (Kwon et al. 1993, Kwon 2001, Min et al. 2004). However, this species can be distinguished from other sympatric Siphonaria species by its thinner, regularly spaced primary ribs, siphonal groove with two radial ribs, undulated margin and dark brown-coloured interior (Fig. 2cF). Yokogawa et al. (2010) described two types from S. japonica, based on the combination of morphological, molecula, and ecological data, as the “tall form” and the “short form”. The tall form is characterised by weak radial ribs over the shell margin and alternating sized (thick and thin) radial ribs, while the short form has projected radial ribs over the shell margin and generally thick radial ribs. The Korean S. japonica morphologically matches the “tall form”. A comprehensive analysis of shell morphological data, coupled with molecular sequence information from broader sampling of this species, is required to confirm whether the “short form” of S. japonica is also distributed along the Korean sea coast, as previously reported in Japan (Yokogawa et al. 2010). Our phylogenetic tree indicates that S. japonica is positioned basal amongst selected Siphonariidae species in the north-western Pacific, with 99% bootstrap support value (Fig. 4). This species exhibits relatively high sequence divergence from other Siphonaria species, ranging from 28.89% (S. zelandica) to 33.81% (S. subatra) (Table 2).

Siphonaria javanica (Lamarck, 1819)

Nomenclature

Siphonaria (Siphonaria) javanica: Lee and Min 2002: 146 [checklist]; Min et al. 2004: 334, fig. 1054.

Siphonaria javanica: Noseworthy et al. 2007: 90 [checklist].

Distribution

Japan (Okinawa island), Malaysia, Palau, Indonesia and northeast Australia.

Type locality: Indonesia; Java Island.

Taxon discussion

This species was initially included by Lee and Min (2002) in their checklist. Later, Min et al. (2004) described the shell characters of this species as having a large shell size (SL 20 mm, SW 18 mm, SH 9 mm) and white primary ribs with 2–3 thin secondary ribs in the interspaces. However, the shell characters in their description do not align with the original description of S. javanica provided by Lamarck (1819) or the subsequent studies by Morrison (1972) and Jenkins and Köhler (2024). The original description of S. javanica is brief, noting that the species possesses ‘white radiating ribs and crenated margin’ (translation from Latin). Morrison (1972) further noted that S. javanica was readily distinguished from other congeneric species by its high conical shell with buttress-like strong white radial ribs. Jenkins and Köhler (2024) provided a further detailed description of S. javanica by designating a lectotype and refined its taxonomy by clarifying its diagnostic characteristics. Their study also emphasised that S. javanica possesses well-developed primary ribs that extend beyond the shell margin, resulting in a coarsely undulated shell margin. This contrasts with the shell image provided by Min et al. (2004), which depicts the species with a smooth shell margin. Given the restricted distribution range of S. javanica to Indonesia and Timor-Leste, as clarified by the recent revision in Jenkins and Köhler (2024), Morrison (1972) and the discordance between the shell description of Korean “S. javanica” samples and both the original and subsequent descriptions, it is likely that the previously reported Korean specimens of “S. javanica” are likely misidentifications of S. japonica. Further studies with broader taxon sampling are necessary to resolve this taxonomic issue.

Siphonaria laciniosa (Linnaeus, 1758)

Nomenclature

Siphonaria laciniosa: Kwon et al. 1993: 335, fig. 61-4.

Siphonaria (Siphonaria) laciniosa: Kwon 2001: 191, fig. 721.

Siphonaria (Mestosiphon) laciniosa: Lee and Min 2002 [checklist]: 146, fig. 268; Min et al. 2004: 336, fig. 1059; Noseworthy et al. 2007: 90 [checklist].

Distribution

Persian Gulf, Red Sea, Samaoan Islands, Tonga, Fiji (Morrison 1972).

Type locality: India.

Taxon discussion

Kwon et al. (1993) first reported the occurrence of this species in Korea, noting its high shell height (SL 20 mm, SW 18 mm, SH 9.4 mm), with approximately 50 radial ribs and a pointed apex. Subsequent literature described this species as having less pronounced radial ribs, with white spots along the inner shell margin (Kwon 2001, Min et al. 2004), which are shell features also commonly observed in some individuals of S. japonica. Jenkins and Köhler (2024) recently designated S. laciniosa as a “nomen dubium”, highlighting the “utter confusion” in its original description and subsequent literature. Jenkins and Köhler (2024) noted that many type specimens attributed to S. laciniosa are either lost or represent mixed lots. Given the substantial taxonomic confusion regarding the validity of S. laciniosa and the morphological overlap between Korean specimens previously identified as S. laciniosa (Kwon et al. 1993, Kwon 2001, Min et al. 2004) and S. japonica (as observed in this study), it is likely that the earlier records of S. laciniosa in Korea represent misidentifications of S. japonica. As a result, we excluded S. laciniosa from the list of Korean Siphonaria species.

Siphonaria rucuana Pilsbry, 1904

Nomenclature

Siphonaria rucuana: Kwon et al. 1993: 335, fig. 61-5.

Siphonaria (Siphonaria) rucuana: Kwon 2001: 191, fig. 722; Lee and Min 2002: 146 [checklist]; Min et al. 2004: 335, fig. 1055; Noseworthy et al. 2007: 90 [checklist].

Distribution

Japan (Okinawa Island).

Type locality: Japan; Ryukyu island (Okinawa Island).

Taxon discussion

Kwon et al. (1993) first reported this species in Korea, based on shell morphology, describing it as having a flatly convex shell with a brown apex curving posteriorly and brown intervals with secondary ribs. However, in contrast to this description, Pilsbry (1904) described S. rucuana as having a steeply conic shell with a glossy brown-coloured apex curving posteriorly and dusky-coloured intervals without secondary ribs. These characteristics are consistent with the recent revision of Jenkins and Köhler (2024). Yokogawa et al. (2010) divided S. japonica into two shell forms—“tall form” and “short form” — based on an integrative analysis of their morphology, habitat ecology and allelic frequencies. Compared to these two shell forms of S. japonica, the specimens previously described as S. rucuana in Korean waters (Kwon et al. 1993, Kwon 2001, Min et al. 2004) do not accord with the Pilsbry (1904)'s original description and morphological characters described in the recent revisional study (Jenkins and Köhler 2024). A re-evaluation of prior records of S. rucuana in Korea suggests that the specimens described in Kwon et al. (1993) correspond to the “tall form” of S. japonica, representing the original S. japonica. On the other hand, the other two reports (Kwon 2001, Min et al. 2004) are assumed to correspond to the “short form” of S. japonica discovered first by Yokogawa et al. (2010) in Japan. In addition to these morphological aspects, S. rucuana is known to have a limited geographic distribution, being reported exclusively from Okinawa Island, a subtropical region of Japan (Pilsbry 1904, Oyama et al. 1954, Okutani 2000, Okutani 2017). Given this restricted geographic distribution range and the morphological discrepancies observed in the Korean nominal records of “S. rucuana”, it is likely that these previous records in the Korean malacofauna result from misidentifications.

Siphonaria sirius Pilsbry, 1894

Nomenclature

Siphonaria sirius Pilsbry 1894: 9, 10; Pilsbry 1895: 5, 6, pl. 6, figs. 23–28; Hirase 1941: 94, pl. 121, fig. 16; Hubendick 1945: 29 (cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)); Kuroda and Habe 1952: 86 (cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)); Azuma 1960: 62 (cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)); Kuroda 1960: 43 (cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)); Baker 1964: 159 (cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)); Shikama 1964: 6 (cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)); Habe and Igarashi 1967: 28 (cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)); Inaba 1983: 145 (cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)); Trew 1983: 7 (cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)); Je 1989: 29 [checklist]; Morton and Morton 1983: 298, pl. 1K (cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)); Hylleberg and Kilburn 2003, 2003: 133; White and Dayrat 2012: 68 [checklist]; Dayrat et al. 2014: 269, fig. 5H; Jenkins and Köhler 2024: 115–118, figs. 43E, F, O, P, 44D, E.

Siphonaria (Siphonaria) sirius: Hubendick 1946: 50, 51, pl. 3, figs. 24–27.

Siphonaria (Mestosiphon) sirius: Habe and Kikuchi 1960: 60 (cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)); Kira 1962: 200, 201, text-fig, pl. 69, fig. 12a, b (cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)); Habe 1971: 15, pl. 4, fig. 12 (cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)).

Anthosiphonaria sirius: Kuroda et al. 1971: 483, 484, fig. 9; Inaba 1983: 145 (cited from) ; Je 1989: 29 [checklist]; Choe 1992: 748, 749, pl. 126, fig. 223; Fukuda et al. 1992: 76, pl. 23, fig. 361a, b (cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)).

Siphonaria laciniosa forma sirius: Christiaens 1980a: 79.

Siphonaria laciniosa: Springsteen and Leobrera 1986: 285, pl. 81, fig. 19 (non Siphonaria laciniosa (Linneaus, 1758); cited from Jenkins and Köhler (2024)).

Siphonaria subatra: Je 1989: 29 [checklist].

Siphonacmea oblongata: Je 1989: 29 [checklist].

Siphonaria (Anthosiphonaria) sirius: Kwon et al. 1993: 334, fig. 61-2; Higo et al. 1999: 402, G4977 [checklist]; Kwon 2001: 191, fig. 725; Min et al. 2004: 336, fig. 1058; Okutani 2000: 815, pl. 405, fig. 5; Noseworthy et al. 2007: 90 [checklist]; Okutani 2017: 1101, pl. 403. fig. 5.

Materials   Download as CSV 
  1. scientificName:
    Siphonaria sirius
    ; kingdom:
    Animalia
    ; phylum:
    Mollusca
    ; class:
    Gastropoda
    ; order:
    Siphonariida
    ; family:
    Siphonariidae
    ; genus:
    Siphonaria
    ; specificEpithet:
    sirius
    ; scientificNameAuthorship:
    Pilsbry, 1894
    ; country:
    Korea
    ; locality:
    Dokdo-ri, Ulleung-eup, Ulleung-gun, Gyeongsangbuk-do
    ; verbatimCoordinates:
    37°14'20.12"N 131°52'05.74"E
    ; eventDate:
    2016-06-22
    ; individualCount:
    1
    ; occurrenceID:
    D54B007E-530E-5A64-9E37-238C909DFC8B
  2. scientificName:
    Siphonaria sirius
    ; kingdom:
    Animalia
    ; phylum:
    Mollusca
    ; class:
    Gastropoda
    ; order:
    Siphonariida
    ; family:
    Siphonariidae
    ; genus:
    Siphonaria
    ; specificEpithet:
    sirius
    ; scientificNameAuthorship:
    Pilsbry, 1894
    ; country:
    Korea
    ; locality:
    Sagye-ro, Andeok-myeon,Seogwipo-si, Jeju-do
    ; verbatimCoordinates:
    33°13'58.7"N 126°22'23.8"E
    ; verbatimCoordinateSystem:
    33°13'13.2"N 126°17'42.0"E
    ; eventDate:
    2022-04-21
    ; individualCount:
    1
    ; occurrenceID:
    C0A81431-17F4-52C1-891F-62FF72C4302D
  3. scientificName:
    Siphonaria sirius
    ; kingdom:
    Animalia
    ; phylum:
    Mollusca
    ; class:
    Gastropoda
    ; order:
    Siphonariida
    ; family:
    Siphonariidae
    ; genus:
    Siphonaria
    ; specificEpithet:
    sirius
    ; scientificNameAuthorship:
    Pilsbry, 1894
    ; country:
    Korea
    ; locality:
    Irun-myeon,, Geoje-si, Gyeongsangnam-do
    ; verbatimCoordinates:
    34°58'34.9"N 128°41'18.18"E
    ; eventDate:
    2023-04-19
    ; individualCount:
    2
    ; occurrenceID:
    BEE8EC41-E8D8-5759-BB91-328F2C2C0A3E
  4. scientificName:
    Siphonaria sirius
    ; kingdom:
    Animalia
    ; phylum:
    Mollusca
    ; class:
    Gastropoda
    ; order:
    Siphonariida
    ; family:
    Siphonariidae
    ; genus:
    Siphonaria
    ; specificEpithet:
    sirius
    ; scientificNameAuthorship:
    Pilsbry, 1894
    ; country:
    Korea
    ; locality:
    Namyang-ri, Seo-myeon, Ulleung-gun, Gyeongsangbuk-do
    ; verbatimCoordinates:
    37°27'35.6"N 130°51'27.0"E
    ; eventDate:
    2023-05-23
    ; individualCount:
    3
    ; occurrenceID:
    2213E690-E902-5F33-99A8-212A4C10304D
  5. scientificName:
    Siphonaria sirius
    ; kingdom:
    Animalia
    ; phylum:
    Mollusca
    ; class:
    Gastropoda
    ; order:
    Siphonariida
    ; family:
    Siphonariidae
    ; genus:
    Siphonaria
    ; specificEpithet:
    sirius
    ; scientificNameAuthorship:
    Pilsbry, 1894
    ; country:
    Korea
    ; locality:
    Mendehaean-gil, Tongyeong-si, Gyeongsangnam-do
    ; verbatimCoordinates:
    34°50'37.8"N 128°26'36.0"E
    ; eventDate:
    2023-06-21
    ; individualCount:
    2
    ; occurrenceID:
    37D006D8-B765-5917-A845-CD6DD8473CD9
  6. scientificName:
    Siphonaria sirius
    ; kingdom:
    Animalia
    ; phylum:
    Mollusca
    ; class:
    Gastropoda
    ; order:
    Siphonariida
    ; family:
    Siphonariidae
    ; genus:
    Siphonaria
    ; specificEpithet:
    sirius
    ; scientificNameAuthorship:
    Pilsbry, 1894
    ; country:
    Korea
    ; locality:
    Guryongpo-eup, Nam-gu, Pohang-si, Gyeongsangbuk-do
    ; verbatimCoordinates:
    35°57'05.7"N 129°33'04.4"E
    ; eventDate:
    2023-07-23
    ; individualCount:
    1
    ; occurrenceID:
    2A53BAB4-3A3B-59CA-8E8A-716A5BC80FD6

Description

Measurements: SL 11.23–19.63 mm, SW 9.09–15.62 mm, SH 2.87–4.93 mm.

Shell (Fig. 2d) solid, oval, small to medium in size (in examined specimens, SL 11.23–19.63 mm), low in height (about 1/4 of its length). Exterior colour greyish-brown or blackish-brown. Shell surface with 5­–11 strong, white-coloured primary radial ribs. Interspaces between the primary radial ribs with 1­–8 thinner secondary ribs, coloured white, sometimes same as shell colour. Apex often eroded, located central of the shell. Shell margin prominently undulated by primary ribs. Anterior slope slightly convex, posterior slope nearly straight. Siphonal groove protruded with one radial rib on outer shell surface. Interior colour reddish-brown to black with white bands, sometimes white or pale-coloured at centre.

Radula (Fig. 3e, f) dentition formulae 34:1:34 (in specimens measuring SL 14.69 mm, SW 11.80 mm, SH 3.89 mm). Each transverse row with narrow central rachidian tooth flanked by symmetrical half rows with lateral teeth, decreasing in size outwards. Rachidian tooth (Fig. 3e) short, approximately one-third length of lateral tooth, bud-shaped, middle widest, tapering gently towards the top with sharply-pointed cusp. Innermost lateral teeth (first 15 lateral teeth), each tooth consisting of mesocone and ectocone; mesocone bicuspid, with U-shaped cleft; ectocone shorter, sharp (Fig. 3e). Outermost lateral teeth (remaining 19 lateral teeth) with short and sharply-pointed endocone, ectocone and mesocone; mesocone subquadrate (Fig. 3f).

Distribution

Korea, China, Japan, Philippines, Singapore, Indonesia (Sumatra Island) and Vietnam.

Type locality: Japan; Sagami, Kashiurazaki, Boshiu (Boso Peninsula).

Habitat: On rocky substrate in middle to low intertidal zones (Fig. 2dG).

Taxon discussion

This species is clearly distinguished from other Korean sympatric species (S. acmaeoides and S. japonica) by its flat shell, remarkably extended white radial ribs, siphonal groove with a single radial rib and pale-coloured inner centre (Fig. 2d). It closely resembles S. atra Quoy and Gaimard, 1833, by having a flat shell and strongly stretched radial ribs. Christiaens (1980a) noted that S. sirius represents one of the three forms of S. laciniosa (Linnaeus, 1758); (S. laciniosa forma sirius, S. laciniosa forma atra (representing S. atra Quoy and Gaimard, 1833) and S. laciniosa forma subatra (representing S. subatra Pilsbry, 1904). He reported no differences in niche selection between S. atra and S. sirius, both of which inhabit highly exposed rocky substrates in the low tidal zone at Ping Chau, Hong Kong. However, the two species differ in colouration and the number of ribs in the siphonal groove. While S. atra has a dusky brown shell with radial ribs of the same colour (sometimes paler than the interspaces) and a siphonal groove with two radial ribs, S. sirius is characterised by a black or dark brown-coloured shell with solid white radial ribs and a siphonal groove with only one radial rib. In the radula formula, as mentioned in the cases of S. acmaeoides and S. japonica, Siphonaria species exhibits high levels of intraspecific variation. Similarly, the radula formulae of S. sirius reported in previous studies showed considerable variation depending on the authority, ranging from 40:1:40 (Hubendick 1946) to 34:1:34 (Christiaens 1980a). The radula formula (34:1:34) observed in this study is consistent with the finding of Christiaens (1980a). The phylogenetic tree shows that S. sirius forms a sister group with S. atra and S. subatra receiving 99% bootstrap value (Fig. 4). The p-distances within S. sirius species range from 0.16% to 0.79%, while this species shows high sequence divergence from other congeneric species ranging from 22.38% (S. atra) to 31.90% (S. japonica) (Table 2).

Discussion

Previously, a total of seven Siphonaria species have been sparsely reported in Korea, based solely on external shell morphologies that has often resulted in taxonomic complications, including misidentification of species due to their remarkably high ecophenotypic variations. From a comprehensive analysis of shell morphology, radula structure and molecular analysis of mtDNA cox1 sequences in this study, three species (S. acmaeoides, S. japonica and S. sirius) have been confirmed to occur in Korea. The three Korean Siphonaria species commonly share the presence of secondary ribs and often exhibit an eroded apex as they grow (Fig. 2). However, they are distinguished from each other by the number of primary ribs: 14–17 (in S. acmaeoides), 17–23 (in S. japonica) and 5–11 (in S. sirius), respectively. Furthermore, their primary ribs vary in thickness, elevation and spacing: S. acmaeoides has wide, low, unevenly spaced ribs; S. japonica has thin, moderately elevated, evenly spaced ribs; and S. sirius has wide, moderately elevated, unevenly spaced ribs. The morphology of the siphonal groove also varies amongst the species: S. acmaeoides has an indistinct groove with uncountable radial ribs, S. japonica has a weakly projected groove with two radial ribs and S. sirius has a strongly projected groove with a single radial rib. Very recently, Jenkins and Köhler (2024) compared the three species (S. acmaeoides, S. japonica and S. sirius) in their shell morphology and reproductive system, including the morphology of the spermatophore. Their shell morphology comparison focused on a set of characters such as the solidity and crenulation of the shell margin, which are less informative for distinguishing sympatric species due to substantial intraspecific variation that complicates precise species identification. Nevertheless, they provided anatomical comparisons, noting that S. acmaeoides differs from S. japonica by having a smaller accessory organ and bursa copulatrix, a shorter flagellum and a short drop-like spermatophore. In contrast, S. sirius has a larger accessory organ and a spermatophore lacking barbs. In radula morphology, S. acmaeoides has only a mesocone in the innermost lateral teeth, whereas both S. japonica and S. sirius possess a mesocone with sharply-pointed ectocone in the inner lateral teeth (Fig. 3). Despite these distinct morphological features, the radula formulae described in previous studies, including our observations, showed considerable individual variations (Hubendick 1946, Christiaens 1980a).

Our phylogenetic analysis using mtDNA cox1 sequences of these three Korean Siphonaria species and some other congeneric species confirmed their morphology-based species identification (Fig. 4). The resulting tree indicated that the mtDNA cox1 sequences determined from S. acmaeoides, S. japonica and S. sirius respectively formed monophyletic groups, corroborating their identification based on morphological characteristics. A significantly high sequence gap was observed between the lowest intraspecific distance (3.33%) and the highest interspecific distance (27.94%) amongst these three species. Interestingly, S. acmaeoides was found as closely related to S. zelandica, showing a relatively low genetic divergence (5.71–6.51%; Table 2). S. acmaeoides is known to be distributed in Japan, Korea (Kuroda et al. 1971, Choe 1992, Okutani 2000, Cheng et al. 2005, Yokogawa et al. 2010, Okutani 2017), whereas S. zelandica is found along the southern coasts of Australia (Quoy and Gaimard 1833, Jenkins 1983). Dayrat et al. (2014) proposed the possibility of an extensive distribution of S. zelandica ranging from Japan to Australia and suggested that S. acmaeoides could be a junior synonym of S. zelandica. However, Jenkins and Köhler (2024) confirmed that S. acmaeoides and S. zelandica are distinct species, based on comparative analyses of shell morphology, soft-body anatomy and mitochondrial phylogenetics. Unlike the three Siphonaria species confirmed to occur in Korea, the taxonomic validity of the other four species (S. coreensis, S. javanica, S. laciniosa and S. rucuana), previously reported from Korean waters is questionable. Despite extensive follow-up efforts over nearly the last two decades, these species have rarely been found. In particular, the shell images and morphological features described in the previous Korean literature do not closely match the original descriptions, but instead appear very similar to S. japonica, one of the most widely and abundantly found Siphonaria species in the north-western Pacific, including the Korean coastline. Moreover, none of these studies provided detailed descriptions of diagnostic characters and their species identifications were based solely on shell characteristics, raising questions about the taxonomic validity of their conclusions.

In conclusion, many molluscan species, including Siphonaria species, exhibit a high degree of morphological plasticity in shell shape (including sculptures), size and colour, which can vary significantly depending on environmental conditions. These variations in shell morphology make it challenging to differentiate species based on morphology alone, often resulting in various taxonomic errors, such as misidentifications, overlooking cryptic species diversity or a plethora of nominal species. Our taxonomic review incorporating both morphological and molecular data revealed that Korean Siphonaria species also display a wide range of shell morphological variations within species (e.g. shell colour, number of radial ribs and the slope of the anterior and posterior shell). Moreover, in many cases — including those observed in the present study — some species exhibiting a wide range of shell morphological variations are often found co-occurring in the same intertidal habitats. A comprehensive analysis of integrated morphological and molecular data, obtained through extensive taxon sampling along the Korean coastline can provide better resolution to address taxonomic ambiguities amongst Siphonaria species.

Acknowledgements

This work was supported by a grant from the National Institute of Biological Resources (NIBR), funded by the Ministry of Environment (MOE) of the Republic of Korea (NIBR202231206) and the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF) grant funded by the Korea government (MSIT) (2020R1A2C2005393) to JKP and by Global-Learning & Academic research institution for Masters'·PhD students and Postdocs (LAMP) Program of the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF) grant funded by the Ministry of Education (No. RS-2023-00301914) to UWH.

References

login to comment