Biodiversity Data Journal :
Research Article
|
Corresponding author: Hristo Peshev (hristopeshev.eu@gmail.com), Emilian Stoynov (pirin@fwff.org)
Academic editor: Ivan Traykov
Received: 05 Jul 2021 | Accepted: 16 Aug 2021 | Published: 23 Aug 2021
© 2021 Hristo Peshev, Atanas Grozdanov, Elena Kmetova–Biro, Ivelin Ivanov, Georgi Stoyanov, Rigas Tsiakiris, Simeon Marin, Saša Marinković, Goran Sušić, Emanuel Lisichanets, Irena Hribšek, Zoran Karić, Sven Kapelj, Lachezar Bonchev, Emilian Stoynov
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Peshev H, Grozdanov A, Kmetova–Biro E, Ivanov I, Stoyanov G, Tsiakiris R, Marin S, Marinković S, Sušić G, Lisichanets E, Hribšek I, Karić Z, Kapelj S, Bonchev L, Stoynov E (2021) New insight into spatial ecology of Griffon Vulture (Gyps fulvus) on the Balkans provides opportunity for focusing conservation actions for a threatened social scavenger. Biodiversity Data Journal 9: e71100. https://doi.org/10.3897/BDJ.9.e71100
|
The knowledge in the behaviour and movement of endangered species is of key importance for the precise targeting and assessing the efficiency of nature conservation actions, especially considering vultures, which explore vast areas to locate ephemeral and unpredictable food resources. Therefore, a total of 51 Griffon Vultures (Gyps fulvus) from both the re-introduced population and the autochthonous Balkan Peninsula (Balkans) colonies have been tagged with GPS/GSM transmitters in recent years, in order to study their seasonal and spatial distribution. The current study presents the analysis of the high-resolution GPS location data, acquired between January 2016 and March 2021. A total of 1,138,383 locations (an average number of 23,716 ± 18,886 positions per bird, ranged between 2,515 and 76,431 of total fixes per bird; n=48) were used to estimate the home range size and identify the traditional foraging areas and roosting sites of the birds during the wintering, migration/roaming and summering periods. Our results reveal that Griffon Vultures movement activity and home range size varied considerably throughout the annual cycle, especially between their wintering and summering grounds, while exhibiting significant overlapping amongst the tracked individuals. Specifically, immature Griffon Vultures travel long distances across all Balkan Peninsula countries, but always gather with conspecifics, showing strong fidelity to active breeding/roosting sites. The total home range 95% area of the Griffon Vulture population on the Balkans was estimated at 39,986.4 km² and the 50% core area at 1,545.42 km² (n = 48). All tracked birds were found to either visit or frequently use (> 95% of the time) the same seven vulture key zones on the Balkan Peninsula – one in Serbia, one shared between North Macedonia and Bulgaria, one shared between Bulgaria and Greece, two entirely lying in Bulgaria, one in western Greece and one shared between Kvarner Archipelago islands in Croatia and the Julian Alps - Italy, Austria and Slovenia. Several smaller sub-zones were also defined within these general ones. The seven key zones form a coherent network and are used as stepping stones for Griffon Vultures during their migration movements and roaming, but also wintering and summering. The observed concentration tendency of Griffon Vultures on the Balkans and the predictability of their temporal and spatial presence should be used to precisely target, address and substantially increase the efficiency of the conservation measures in this marginal and, thus, still vulnerable meta-population.
Griffon Vulture, conservation, GPS tracking, home range, species protection, wildlife movements, Vulture Safe Areas, dynamic Brownian bridge movement model, dBBMM, vulture key zones, Balkan Peninsula
Griffon Vulture (Gyps fulvus Hablizl, 1783) is an obligate scavenger, gregarious, soaring over large areas for foraging, cliff dwelling bird of prey, formerly widely spread on the Balkan Peninsula (Balkans), but faced a dramatic decline in 20th century (
Since the 1980s, due to intensification of the conservation activities in Bulgaria, Serbia, Croatia and Crete, the Griffon Vulture increased locally, although some colonies became deserted (e.g. Bosnia and Herzegovina) or continued to decline, remaining on the verge of extinction, primarily in mainland Greece and North Macedonia (
Although the places where the species is, or was until recently, breeding on the Balkan Peninsula are generally known by local conservation groups and presented in various technical reports, official documents and local studies (
The movements of Griffon Vultures have been studied elsewhere (
Griffon Vulture is listed as "Least concern" globally and in Europe in the IUCN Red List (
The aim of the current study is to present and analyse the territory use and sojourn patterns of Griffon Vulture, based on high-resolution GPS tracking for the first time on a regional Balkan Peninsula scale. The home range of the species, its core areas, seasonal sojourn and roosting places are revealed on regional and local level and the conservation implications of these findings are discussed.
In the current study, a total of 51 Griffon Vultures of different ages were equipped with GPS/GSM transmitters in Bulgaria (n = 43), Greece (n = 6) and North Macedonia (n = 2) (Table
Griffon Vulture individuals tracked; GPS transmitter type used; manner of device deployment; age; tagging location; tracking period and number of GPS fixes received per individial. Different groups, based on the type of bird according to the method of capturing and tagging with GPS transmitter, are provided as: 1. "Wild caught" - the bird was a healthy wild individual, native to Balkans, intentionally captured and marked; 2. "Wild/Rehabilitated" - the bird was a wild individual, native to Balkans, captured in distress and rehabilitated and then marked upon release back into the wild; 3. "Re-introduced" - the bird originated from a re-introduction programme - either captive bred in a zoo or translocated after rehabilitation and marked upon release into the wild.
Tag | Transmitter type and model | Tagging location | Year of fledging | Way of capturing to deploy the transmitter | Start date | End date | Received GPS coordinates on the Balkans | Tracking days with data used in calculations | Core area 50%, km2 | Homerange 95%, km2 |
5 - Petitsata | OT - 30 | Kresna Gorge | 2012 | Wild caught | 19.3.2020 | 26.3.2021 | 20492 | 373 | 8.532 | 359.259 |
1H - Wild 1H |
OT - P33 | Kresna Gorge | 2016 | Wild caught | 12.7.2017 | 13.5.2018 | 19996 | 306 | 162.79 | 4176.175 |
1X - Terziev |
OT - P33 | Dadia | 2017 |
Wild/ Rehabilitated |
22.1.2018 | 26.3.2021 | 74306 | 1160 | 33.33 | 2059.875 |
2H - Wild 2H |
OT - P33 | Kresna Gorge | 2016 | Wild caught | 12.7.2017 | 20.6.2020 | 70453 | 1075 | 75.564 | 2890.259 |
56 - Survivor |
OT - P33 | Kresna Gorge | 2014 | Re-introduced | 12.7.2017 | 20.9.2018 | 32150 | 436 | 33.174 | 5320.03 |
A4 - Vrachan |
OT - P33 | Vrachanski Balkan | 2011 | Re-introduced | 7.11.2017 | 16.9.2019 | 32954 | 678 | 4.186 | 320.095 |
Alexis | OT - P33 | Messolonghi | 2017 | Wild/ Rehabilitated | 5.8.2017 | 27.5.2019 | 7555 | 93 | 91.675 | 3163.986 |
B65 - Parvolet | OT - P33 | Sinite Kamani | 2016 | Re-introduced | 21.7.2019 | 27.3.2021 | 37756 | 616 | 10.426 | 493.88 |
B69 - Balkan |
OT - P33 | Kresna Gorge | 2016 | Wild caught | 18.8.2017 | 6.2.2018 | 8794 | 173 | 24.20 | 1978.353 |
B70-UG - Barcelona | OT - P33 | Kresna Gorge | 2015 | Re-introduced | 18.7.2017 | 7.9.2017 | 4602 | 52 | 2.481 | 395.826 |
B71-XU - Barca | OT - P33 | Kresna Gorge | 2015 | Re-introduced | 3.8.2017 | 14.10.2017 | 5429 | 73 | 1.437 | 184.891 |
BY1- Gorlits | OT - 30 | Kresna Gorge | 2018 | Wild caught | 22.2.2020 | 26.3.2021 | 24162 | 399 | 11.246 | 2380.805 |
BY3 - Svetislav 2 | OT - 50 | Kresna Gorge | 2018 | Wild caught | 22.2.2020 | 23.1.2021 | 16874 | 337 | 12.737 | 1434.072 |
BY7 - Michev | OT - 30 | Kresna Gorge | adult | Wild caught | 3.6.2020 | 14.7.2020 | 3664 | 50 | 34.049 | 909.422 |
C1-M - Kresna | OT - P33 | Vrachanski Balkan | 2016 | Re-introduced | 8.2.2018 | 16.9.2019 | 41357 | 586 | 4.392 | 275.712 |
C5 - Sunchitsa |
OT - 50 | Kavadarci | 2019 | Wild caught | 30.10.2019 | 27.3.2021 | 22230 | 329 | 13.736 | 1951.845 |
C7 - Svetislav |
OT - 50 / OT - P33 | Kavadarci/ Kresna Gorge | 2019 | Wild caught | 4.9.2020 | 26.11.2020 | 5547 | 84 | 31.373 | 921.962 |
C9 - Rakitna | OT - P33 | Kresna Gorge | 2018 | Wild caught | 24.6.2020 | 27.3.2021 | 19015 | 277 | 61.214 | 1823.193 |
Defile | OT - 30 | Kresna Gorge | 2016 | Wild caught | 29.7.2020 | 26.3.2021 | 11187 | 241 | 5.372 | 370.085 |
E1 - Poison detective | OT - P33 | Vrachanski Balkan | 2014 | Wild caught | 16.12.2020 | 27.3.2021 | 3177 | 101 | 2.413 | 83.473 |
EX - Extreme |
OT - 50 | Kresna Gorge | 2019 | Wild caught | 1.2.2021 | 27.3.2021 | 2515 | 55 | 2.114 | 23.197 |
F4 - Stresher | OT - 30 | Vrachanski Balkan | 2018 | Re-introduced | 6.12.2019 | 26.3.2021 | 22863 | 477 | 2.852 | 143.784 |
F6 - Zelen | OT - 30 | Vrachanski Balkan | 2018 | Re-introduced | 6.12.2019 | 26.3.2021 | 27130 | 477 | 4.298 | 191.242 |
GD-22 -Giannis | OT - 50 | Messolonghi | Wild/ Rehabilitated | 5.3.2020 | 27.3.2021 | 28774 | 388 | 72.197 | 1579.987 | |
GS - Athanasios | OT - 30 | Messolonghi | 2020 | Wild/ Rehabilitated | 24.1.2021 | 27.3.2021 | 2929 | 63 | 9.368 | 137.276 |
H1 - Juanjo |
OT - P33 | Kotel | 2016 | Wild caught | 8.3.2017 | 28.10.2019 | 68012 | 965 | 1.203 | 216.167 |
HW - Struma | OT - P33 | Kresna Gorge | 2015 | Re-introduced | 24.6.2020 | 27.3.2021 | 18020 | 277 | 6.439 | 320.247 |
K2M - Mulhouse | OT - P33 | Kresna Gorge | 2016 | Re-introduced | 3.8.2017 | 1.2.2018 | 11809 | 183 | 3.639 | 570.129 |
K3A-B2 | OT - 30 | Messolonghi | 2018 | Wild/ Rehabilitated | 6.3.2020 | 30.10.2020 | 14463 | 239 | 24.37 | 470.309 |
K5M - Baumgart |
OT - P33 | Kotel | 2011 | Re-introduced | 24.1.2017 | 27.1.2018 | 21918 | 369 | 3.640 | 141.962 |
K7A-B5 - Dinos |
OT - 30 | Messolonghi | adult | Wild/ Rehabilitated | 6.3.2020 | 26.3.2021 | 25435 | 386 | 106.767 | 3059.814 |
K9U - Kotel | OT - P33 | Kresna Gorge | 2014 | Re-introduced | 3.8.2017 | 13.5.2018 | 19775 | 284 | 156.375 | 5308.372 |
M2 - Lars | OT - P33 | Sinite Kamani | 2017 | Re-introduced | 21.3.2019 | 19.8.2020 | 40793 | 518 | 6.903 | 248.354 |
OX - De Doue | OT - P33 | Kresna Gorge | 2016 | Re-introduced | 15.12.2016 | 18.2.2018 | 24310 | 431 | 37.522 | 1642.845 |
P-B2F - Niki | OT - P33 | Vrachanski Balkan | 2017 | Wild caught | 10.10.2017 | 19.2.2018 | 6951 | 133 | 27.995 | 479.693 |
V3 - Poison Spy | OT - P33 | Kresna Gorge | 2017 | Re-introduced | 13.3.2018 | 26.3.2021 | 76431 | 1097 | 31.91 | 4690.052 |
V5 - Boev | OT - P33 | Kresna Gorge | 2017 | Re-introduced | 12.2.2019 | 24.4.2019 | 4736 | 72 | 1.765 | 69.608 |
V8 - Sainte Croix | OT - P33 | Kresna Gorge | 2017 | Re-introduced | 3.5.2018 | 17.12.2019 | 36784 | 595 | 7.128 | 1290.039 |
XE - Hemus | OT - 30 | Vrachanski Balkan | 2017 | Re-introduced | 1.7.2020 | 27.3.2021 | 15157 | 270 | 2.853 | 186.603 |
XJ - Nikola | OT - P33 | Kotel | 2015 | Re-introduced | 15.3.2019 | 27.3.2021 | 53929 | 733 | 2.851 | 114.437 |
Y1 - Gorlitz | OT - P33 | Kresna Gorge | 2017 | Wild caught | 24.1.2020 | 26.3.2021 | 28916 | 428 | 33.858 | 3042.697 |
Y2- Whitley (WFN) | OT - 30 | Kresna Gorge | 2017 | Wild caught | 22.2.2020 | 24.3.2021 | 15968 | 371 | 13.978 | 1481.232 |
Y4 - Vrachan 2 | OT - P33 | Kresna Gorge | 2018 | Wild caught | 24.1.2020 | 6.10.2020 | 19530 | 257 | 34.959 | 2568.986 |
Y5 - Alexis 2 | OT - P33 | Kresna Gorge | 2018 | Wild caught | 1.11.2019 | 26.3.2021 | 24041 | 347 | 39.265 | 3889.373 |
Y6 - Juanjo 2 | OT - P33 | Kresna Gorge | 2018 | Wild caught | 1.11.2019 | 26.3.2021 | 31414 | 512 | 41.639 | 966.519 |
Y8 - Paris 2 | OT - P33 | Kresna Gorge | 2018 | Wild caught | 22.2.2020 | 25.3.2021 | 19709 | 393 | 50.644 | 2273.77 |
Y9 - Sinanitsa | OT - P33 | Kresna Gorge | 2019 | Wild caught | 24.6.2020 | 27.3.2021 | 9061 | 111 | 86.372 | 1907.081 |
Z7 - Izvor | OT - 30 | Vrachanski Balkan | 2017 | Re-introduced | 1.9.2020 | 27.3.2021 | 5310 | 202 | 4.571 | 191.373 |
C2 - Nelson | OT - P33 | Kresna Gorge | 2018 | Wild caught | 19.09.2018 | 26.10.2018 | 1016 | 15 | ||
W0818 -Bistritsa | OT - 30 | Kresna Gorge | 2019 | Wild caught | 4.9.2020 | 26.3.2021 | 2373 | 33 | ||
A4- Ezerets | OT - P33 | Kresna Gorge | 2019 | Wild caught | 4.9.2020 | 27.3.2021 | 3536 | 38 |
During the transmitter fitting, the age of the wild-captured birds was determined and recorded by year of hatching using the moulting pattern age determination in Griffon Vulture in line with
The GPS/GSM transmitters (produced by Ornitela UAB - www.ornitela.com) weighed from 30 to 50 g. or < 1% of the body mass of the birds tracked - following the recommendation of < 3% for flying birds (
Bird locations were obtained using a global positioning system (GPS), transmitted via a public mobile phone/internet system network (GSM/GPRS). The devices were programmed to save the location data if birds were outside of the coverage area of the given network operator and then to send it once the transmitter was back within range. GPS fixes were acquired every 10 min during the day (between 0500 and 2000 h UTC+2) with dormancy periods during the night. Prior to analysis, the tracking data were inspected and visualised in the Quantum GIS free and open-source cross-platform desktop geographic information system (
Only locations from the Balkan Peninusla and the related areas in the Alps were used in the current study, while location data from the Middle East (movement and sojourn), where some of the tracked birds moved for wintering, were excluded. In addition, birds that were tracked for less than 50 days after release were excluded from further analysis. Data from 48 tracked Griffon Vultures were used for calculations. The information presented and analysed was collected in the period 2016-2021.
The four seasons were defined by the winter and summer solstices and spring and autumn equinox dates. The split aimed at best reflecting the life cycle and foraging and sojourn patterns of the tracked individuals and to distinguish between wintering, summering, spring and autumn migration, seasonal residence and breeding (for the adult birds). If a given vulture had only sent fixings for less than 50% of a particular season (< 45 days), the data of that vulture for that incomplete season were not included in the overall calculations. This was done in order to avoid allocating significance to occasional sites only visited a small number of times yet reflected in the shorter data sample.
The home range of each vulture was calculated using the dynamic Brownian bridge movement model (dBBMM) (
A 95% dBBMM home range isopleth contour was defined as the general individual home range and 50% dBBMM home range isopleth contour was defined as the core area. We calculated the home ranges for the entire tracking period for all individual birds, as well as the inidividual home ranges for each tracking season. Distinguishing between home ranges used in various times of the year aimed at avoiding the incorrect attribution of high importance sites, where vultures were present for longer periods or throughout the year, as compared to other important sites, however, visited by the birds only in particular parts of the year.
Differences in home range size, seasonal home range size and core area were assessed using one way ANOVA tests and LCD for post-hoc comparisons.
For the aims of the current study, "vulture key zones" were defined using the connectivity and coherence of the spatio-temporal presence of the tracked vultures as follows:
We analysed the daily movements of the tracked vultures by dividing their daily tracks into three categories: 1. Days in which the vulture was more than 95% of the time/coordinates in the territory of an already-defined zone; 2. Days in which the tracked vulture is in and out of any of the identified zones and 3. Days in which the tracked vulture has been entirely out of any of the identified zones.
The results, presented below, are based on a total of 1,138,383 GPS coordinate locations (an average number of 23,716 ± 18,886 positions per bird, range 2,515 – 76,431 of total fixes per bird); and an average of 62.99 fixes per day, collected over a total of 18,072 days (average 376.5 ± 276.12 per bird, range 50 – 1,160), acquired from a total of forty eight Griffon Vultures tracked between January 2016 and March 2021.
Based on the location data described above, the mean 95% home range area for all vultures (n = 48) was calculated at 1,431.22 ± 1,472.12 km² (range 23.2 – 5,320.03 km²). At the same time, the mean 50% core area for all studied vultures (n = 48), was estimated at 30.04 ± 37.58 km² (range 1.2 – 162.79 km²). The total coverage of all vulture core areas on the Balkan Peninsula, obtained by overlapping all acquired 50% polygons, was estimated at 1,545.42 km² and the 95% home range was similarly calculated at 39,986.4 km², which can be considered as the actual range of the Griffon Vulture in the region.
There was no significant difference in home range sizes between the three groups of vultures (Wild caught, Wild/Rehabilitated and Re-introduced) (F = 0.801, df = 2, p < 0.455). The individual home range calculations for the overall duration of the tracking period are provided in Table
Тhe seasonal home range estimations are provided in Table
Season | Total number of seasons studied for all birds, n | Core area 50%, km2 | Home range 95%, km2 | ||||||||
mean | median | st. deviation | min | max | mean | median | st. deviation | min | max | ||
Spring | 44 | 34.8602 | 8.9035 | 57.947 | 1.04 | 244.085 | 984.604 | 508.227 | 1120.12 | 14.837 | 4855.93 |
Summer | 55 | 26.2727 | 12.21 | 37.9947 | 1.233 | 193.352 | 1033.56 | 696.312 | 1041.45 | 110.111 | 5292.27 |
Autumn | 50 | 11.5356 | 6.305 | 11.7446 | 0.867 | 48.415 | 421.864 | 225.127 | 477.72 | 16.452 | 2187.2 |
Winter | 56 | 7.76018 | 5.1155 | 9.12612 | 0.096 | 44.963 | 258.682 | 129.543 | 298.938 | 2.1 | 1256.35 |
There was a significant difference in the home range sizes amongst the four seasons (F = 11.51, df = 3, p < 0.001; Fig.
Our results reveal that Griffon Vulture movement activity and home range size vary considerably throughout the seasons (see Figs
Several smaller sub-zones were also defined within the general ones (see Table
Griffon Vulture zones on the Balkans, core areas and home range sizes, sub-zones, type of presence and food sources utilised in the given area (based on field observations and available expert data).
Nº |
Vulture key zone/ Country |
Vultures located in the zone | Area used by vutures, 50% core area, km2 | Area used by vutures, 95% Home range, km2 |
Sub-zone(s) within the main site |
Type of presence |
Food resources used by vultures - Feeding sites (FS) place/name |
1 | Alpo - Adriatic, Austria/ Italy/ Croatia |
K7A-B5, V3, Y8, (n=3) |
291.37 | 6803,04 | Kvarner Archipelago, Croatia (islands of Cres, Krk, Plavnik, Prvich and Pag) | Breeding | Year-round free grazing livestock |
Lago di Cornino Nature Park, Italy | Breeding and summering | Feeding site | |||||
Hohe Tauern National Park, Austria | Summering | Summer livestock grazing | |||||
2 | Western Serbia, Serbia |
56, B69, BY3, K9U, V3, Y1, Y2, Y6, Y8, Y9, (n=10) |
190.22 | 4741.83 | Uvats Gorge, Mileshevka Gorge, Treshnitsa Gorge | Breeding, wintering, summering, on passage | Uvats Gorge FS, Treshnitsa Gorge FS, Year-round grazing livestock |
3 | Vrachanski Balkan Nature Park, Bulgaria |
1X, 56, A4, C1-M, C5, F4, F6, P-B2F, XE, Y1, Z7, E1 (n=12) |
54.17 | 2249.32 | Vrachanski Balkan | Breeding, wintering, summering, on passage | Vrachanski Balkan FS, Year-round grazing livestock |
4 | Eastern Balkan Mountain, Bulgaria |
1X, B65, H1, K5M, M2, V3, XJ, Y1, Y5, (n=9) |
30.416 | 1171.38 | Kotlenska Planina SPA | Breeding, wintering, summering, on passage | Kotel FS, Year-round grazing livestock |
Sinite Kamani Nature Park | Breeding, wintering, summering, on passage | Sinite Kamani FS, Year-round grazing livestock | |||||
5 | Struma and Vardar Velleys, Bulgaria/ North Macedonia |
1H, 2H, 5, 56, A42020, B69, B70-UG, B71-XU, BY1, BY3, BY7, C5, C7, C9, DEFILE, EX, HW, K2M, K9U, OX, V3, V5, V8, W0818, Y1, Y2, Y4, Y5, Y6, Y8, Y9, (n=31) |
190.36 | 7578.93 | Kresna Gorge | Breeding, wintering, summering, on passage | Kresna Gorge FS, Year-round grazing livestock |
Pirin National Park | Summering | Summer livestock grazing | |||||
Demir Kapiya, Tikvesh and Mariovo | Breeding, wintering, summering, on passage | Vitachevo FS, Year-round grazing livestock | |||||
Kaymakchalan | Summering | Summer livestock grazing | |||||
6 | Eastern Rhodopes, Bulgaria/ Greece |
1H,1X, 2H,56, A42020, Alexis, B69, BY1, BY7, C5, C7, C9, H1, K9U, P-B2F, V3, V8, W0818, Y1, Y4, Y5, Y9, (n=22) |
422.63 | 8371.15 | Dadia, Greece | Breeding, wintering, summering, on passage | Dadia FS, Year-round grazing livestock |
Studen Kladenets, Bulgaria | Breeding, wintering, summering, on passage | Studen Kladenets FS, Year-round grazing livestock | |||||
Madjarovo, Bulgaria | Breeding, wintering, summering, on passage | Madjarovo FS, Year-round grazing livestock | |||||
Kompsatos, Greece | Breeding, wintering, summering, on passage | Year-round grazing livestock | |||||
7 | Western Greece, Greece |
1H, 2H, 56, Alexis, C9, GD-22, GS, K3A-B2, K7A-B5, OX, (n=10) |
363.54 | 7242.78 | Akarnanika Mts/ Messolonghi/Embesos | Breeding, wintering, | Winter livestock grazing livestock |
Pindus Mts | Summering, on passage | Summer livestock grazing |
The VKZ extends beyond the borders of the Balkan Peninusla. It is shared amongst Croatia, Italy, Slovenia and Austria (see Fig.
This VKZ lies entirely in Serbia (Fig.
This VKZ lies entirely in Bulgaria (Fig.
This VKZ lies entirely within Bulgaria, centred at the towns of Kotel (
This VKZ is shared between North Macedonia and Bulgaria (Fig.
This VKZ is shared between Bulgaria and Greece, centred at the breeding colonies around Studen Kladenets (
This VKZ lies in south-western continental Greece, with three centres - at Messolonghi (
The studied vultures spent a total of 17,240 days (95.40%) of all days tracked (n = 18,072) entirely in one of the seven key zones identified on the Balkans. In 659 days (3.64% of the time), they were partly in and out of any zone and only in 173 days (0.96%) they were completely outside all the zones outlined.
On the Balkans, Griffon Vultures are less mobile and inhabit smaller home ranges in winter and autumn, as compared to summer and spring, likely related to the fewer daylight hours and the fewer days with suitable weather conditions for soaring flights (
The contemporary Griffon Vulture wintering areas in Western Greece are located mainly near wintering free-ranging transhumant livestock herds along the shoreline - Messolonghi, Akarnanika, Embesos and Varasova, where the weather conditions are mild and allow daily flight activities. In this VKZ, even without vulture feeding sites operation, the vultures are concentrated in winter near existing breeding colonies after being eventually halted by a geographic barrier (Mediterranean Sea surrounding the "Greek" Peninsula) during their southward migration in autumn.
In the period spring to early summer (April-June), the vulture movements and flight distances increase, likely due to the improved weather conditions and the more daylight hours. Adult vultures start breeding and this fixes them largely in the colonies as the central place for foraging (
In the period summer to early autumn (July-October), vultures move to higher parts of the mountains if food is available, concentrating in the following sites: 1. from the Island of Cres and the fore-mountians of the Alps, as well as other parts of the Balkans to Hohe Tauren National Park in Austria and the Julian Alps between Italy and Slovenia; 2. Vrachanski Balkan Nature Park - from fore-mountains to open upland pastures; 3. from Kresna Gorge to Pirin National Park; 4. from Mariovo and Tikvesh to North Macedonia, but also from Kresna Gorge to Kaymakchalan on the border with Greece; and 5. from Messolonghi/Akarnanika/Embesos area to Pindus Mountains (Agrafa, Tzumerka, Karpenisi and others) in Greece. During these months, birds rely less on the vulture feeding sites (supported also by the study of
Although vultures travel large distances and cross state borders and various protected areas (
Seasonal home ranges show differences in size and location according to the specific features of the respective zone.
Out of the known vulture feeding sites in Serbia, Bulgaria, North Macedonia and Greece, the vultures rarely stayed more than an overnight on-passage and were never feeding in other sites, with the exception of several places in Pindus Mountain range that should be given priority for application of urgent vulture conservation measures and to secure them as VSAs, instead of playing roles of ecological traps and thus population sinks (as according to
Based on the current study and knowledge for the Griffon Vulture's movements and sojourn in Balkan Peninsula, another strategically placed historic breeding/roosting sites should be assessed for their potential to be recolonised by the species (either naturally or assisted) and to be managed in a way as to further enlarge the current network of vulture key zones/safe areas.
The present research reveals seven well-distinguished key zones for the remnant and locally-re-introduced nuclei of the Griffon Vulture population on the Balkan Peninsula, clearly outlined by the analysis of the collected telemetry data. The monitored individuals spent virtually the whole period of the research (> 95%) in one or more of those seven key zones or in targeted movements between them, demonstrating an extremly high preference for those environmentally suitable areas, involving also species with strong social interactions.
All of the seven identified Griffon Vulture zones on the Balkans offer similar key benefits for the vultures - suitable breeding/roosting sites with gorges, ravines and cliffs nearby; extensive summer and winter pasturelands; presence of conspecifics and all, but Western Greece, have actively managed vulture feeding stations. The seven key zones form a coherent network and are used as stepping-stones for Griffon Vultures during their migration movements and roaming, but also wintering and summering.
The obtained results are of crucial importance for the conservation of the species on the Balkans as they show that the wide range of management efforts could be specifically targeting particular core areas. The knowledge that social scavengers, such as Griffon Vulture, could be spatially concentrated and could be used elsewhere to precisely target adequate management efforts in space and time.
The telemetry-based conclusions are directly related to the concept of VSA and support the urgent need to actively monitor, control and mitigate all risk factors (such as poisoning, electrocution, collision, poaching etc.) and prevent habitat deterioration (e.g. large scale wind farm development, pastureland abandonment) in these well-defined key zones. This is likely the most cost-effective strategy for the conservation of all vulture species during the human-dominated present (the so-called Anthropocene) on the Balkan Peninsula and elsewhere.
The knowledge of the key characteristics of the present Griffon Vulture key zones, identified in Southeast Europe, will assist the potential establishment of new ones, where colonies of the species have existed in the near past. This could help to further increase the coherence of the network of vulture key zones and facilitate the natural dispersal of the metapopulation, lowering the conservation risks in all remaining single sites.
The study was carried out within the Life for Kresna Gorge LIFE11NAT/BG/363 project of the Fund for Wild Flora and Fauna (2012-2016); the Vultures Return in Bulgaria LIFE08NAT/BG/278 project of Green Balkans and FWFF in Vrachanski Balkan Nature Park and the Eastern Balkan Mountains (2010-2014) and the Vultures Back to Life LIFE14NAT/BG/649 project (2015-ongoing), all of which co-financed by the LIFE financial instrument of EC.
Some of the GPS/GSM transmitters and part of the study and its publication were financially supported by the Whitley Fund for Nature (https://whitleyaward.org/) through the project "Saving the last vultures in Balkans introducing Vulture Safe Areas as a model for scavengers conservation in the Anthropocene".
In addition to that, some GPS/GSM transmitters were purchased within the Balkan Against-poison Project of Vulture Conservation Foundation with the support of MAVA Foundation.