Biodiversity Data Journal :
Data Paper (Biosciences)
|
Corresponding author: Elise McDonald (elise.mcdonald11@gmail.com)
Academic editor: Dominique Zimmermann
Received: 26 Jan 2022 | Accepted: 31 May 2022 | Published: 28 Jul 2022
© 2022 Elise McDonald, Jacob Podesta, Christine Fortuin, Kamal Gandhi
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
McDonald E, Podesta J, Fortuin CC, Gandhi KJ (2022) Expanded range of eight orchid bee species (Hymenoptera, Apidae, Euglossini) in Costa Rica. Biodiversity Data Journal 10: e81220. https://doi.org/10.3897/BDJ.10.e81220
|
|
The Monteverde region of Costa Rica is a hotspot of endemism and biodiversity. The region is, however, disturbed by human activities such as agriculture and urbanisation. This study provides a list of orchid bees (Hymenoptera: Euglossini) compiled from field surveys conducted during January-October 2019 in the premontane wet forest of San Luis, Monteverde, Costa Rica. We collected 36 species of Euglossine bees across four genera. We provide new geographic distribution and elevation data for eight species in two genera. Due to their critical role in the pollination of orchids and other plants, the distribution and abundance of Euglossine bees has relevance to plant biodiversity and conservation efforts. This is especially important in a region with a high diversity of difficult-to-study epiphytic orchids, such as in the Monteverde region.
A total of 2,742 Euglossine male individuals across four genera (Eufriesea, Eulaema, Euglossa and Exaerete) were collected in this study. Updated geographic distributions and elevation ranges were established for eight species of Euglossini in two genera: Eufriesea mussitans (Fabricius, 1787), Eufriesea rufocauda (Kimsey, 1977), Euglossa dodsoni (Moure, 1965), Euglossa dressleri (Moure, 1968), Euglossa hansoni (Moure, 1965), Euglossa ignita (Smith, 1874), Euglossa tridentata (Moure, 1970) and Euglossa turbinifex (Dressler, 1978). These are the first recorded occurrences of these species in the Monteverde region of Costa Rica, according to the Global Biodiversity Information Facility (GBIF) database (https://doi.org/10.15468/9f9kgp). This study also established expanded elevation ranges for Euglossa allosticta, Euglossa bursigera, Euglossa mixta, Euglossa heterosticta and Euglossa maculabris, though these five species have been previously recorded in the Monteverde region and, thus, are not described in detail here. Additionally, our capture of 123 Eufriesea concava individuals is significant, as it indicates its abundance in this region. Prior to this study, there was a single record of E. concava in the Monteverde region, documented in 1993.
Costa Rica, premontane wet forest, Monteverde, orchid bees
Hymenoptera in the tribe Euglossini (orchid bees) are a diverse group of New World tropical pollinators accounting for up to 25% of total bee communities in the Neotropics (
The global decline of bees has been widely observed and is especially pronounced in areas of intense agriculture, urbanisation and pesticide use (
Euglossini vary in abundance with season, with some species (e.g. many Eufriesea spp.) only being active for a few months of the year (
Euglossine bees were sampled in the Monteverde region of Costa Rica at an elevation immediately below the cloud forest (1,100-1,170 m above sea level), in what is considered premontane wet forest. To our knowledge, this area has not been previously sampled for orchid bees. This area was chosen as it provided the opportunity to sample understorey, canopy and open areas to capture a range of diversity in the orchid bee community. In this way, it is more representative of the general state of orchid bee diversity in the region; much of Central America's forests are degraded, with secondary forests and the remaining primary forests predominantly in reserves, in a patchwork of human-managed and semi-natural environments (personal communication, Jacob Podesta). It is, therefore, necessary to understand how Euglossine diversity responds to the anthropogenic changes in their geographic range to provide information for management strategies to promote and maintain orchid bee diversity. We collected a total of 2,742 specimens, represented by 36 species across four genera, all of which were adult males. We provide expanded geographic distribution and elevation ranges for eight bee species.
Three areas of the 62.7 hectare University of Georgia Costa Rica campus were sampled: Forest A (trap locations F1-F5), Forest B (F6-F10) and the open area through the developed part of campus (O1-O10) (Table
List of trap stations, elevation and location in Monteverde, Costa Rica. F = Forest traps, O = open area traps.
Trap Station |
Elevation (m) |
Latitude / Longitude |
F1 |
1158 |
|
F2 |
1168 |
|
F3 |
1154 |
|
F4 |
1121 |
|
F5 |
1137 |
|
F6 |
1095 |
|
F7 |
1092 |
|
F8 |
1083 |
|
F9 |
1055 |
|
F10 |
1041 |
|
O1 |
1084 |
|
O2 |
1081 |
|
O3 |
1085 |
|
O4 |
1084 |
|
O5 |
1080 |
|
O6 |
1094 |
|
O7 |
1096 |
|
O8 |
1093 |
|
O9 |
1092 |
|
O10 |
1083 |
|
Sampling dates and habitat types sampled during each month of the study in 2019 in Monteverde, Costa Rica.
Month |
Sampling Dates |
Areas Sampled |
January |
3-7 January 2019 |
Forest A |
February |
6-10 February 2019 |
Forest A |
March |
9-13 March 2019 |
Forest A |
April |
9-13 April 2019 |
Forest A; Forest B |
May |
30 April - 4 May 2019 |
Forest A |
June |
26-30 May 2019 |
Forest A |
June |
17-21 June 2019 |
Forest A; Open |
July |
1-5 July 2019 |
Forest A; Open |
August |
1-5 August 2019 |
Forest A; Open |
September |
1-5 September 2019 |
Forest A; Open |
October |
30 September- 4 October 2019 |
Forest A; Forest B; Open |
Male Euglossine bees are attracted to baited traps using artificial compounds that mimic those of desired orchids, a method employed regularly by researchers (
The dry season is typically marked by high wind speeds and little rainfall. Dry season sampling occurred January to May 2019. During this time, the five sites and ten traps in Forest A were sampled each month, with Forest B being sampled during the peak dry season in April.
The wet season sampling took place June to October 2019. In addition to the ten traps in Forest A, ten trap sites in the open area were added during the wet season. In October, the peak of wet season, Forest B was added, for a total of 30 operational traps. The Forest B site was sampled during the historical peak dry and wet seasons to provide additional data for comparison. We selected trapping sites where the elevation range along a transect was no more than 100 m.
At each of the habitat types, traps were established along a transect, with each sub-unit being 100 m apart (Fig.
Individuals collected at each trap were placed in an 9.58 cm x 17.78 cm Whirlpack plastic pouch. The bags were padded with tissue paper to prevent the movement of live bees from damaging themselves or other specimens. Each collection bag was labelled with the name of the sampling site, date collected, name of the individual collecting the sample and the trap number. The bees were returned to the laboratory and placed in the freezer for at least 24 hours to ensure that all of the specimens were dead before identification. Specimens were mounted or preserved according to standard protocols as follows:
Standard procedures were followed during specimen sorting and identification in the laboratory. All Euglossine specimens were identified to species level using physical characteristics as described in Roubik and Hanson’s dichotomous key in "Orchid bees of tropical America Biology and Field Guide" (
The resulting specimen collection will be used to provide information for future research and as an education tool. Pollinaria attached to bees at the time of collection were preserved on the specimens for future identification. Specimens of non-target taxa were mounted or preserved in ethanol for future identification.
The study was conducted at the Council on International Educational Exchange (CIEE) Monteverde in Puntarenas Province, San Luis, Monteverde, Costa Rica, formerly known as University of Georgia Costa Rica. This site is positioned on the Pacific slope of the Tilarán Mountain Range and borders two nature preserves. The 62.7 ha campus (centred at 10.2827°N, 84.7985°W) consists of three distinct habitat types: 1) secondary premontane wet forest with 60 years of growth (elevation 1,100-1,170 m); 2) open low-intensity agricultural areas; and 3) areas considered highly modified with roads, multi-use recreation areas and buildings/structures within a 40 m elevation range (Fig.
10.279°N and 10.285°N Latitude; -84.795°W and -84.807°W Longitude.
Tribe Euglossini (Arthropoda: Insecta: Hymenoptera: Apidae: Corbiculata)
Physical descriptions and baseline distribution and elevation data were based on Roubik and Hanson's "Orchid bees of tropical America Biology and Field Guide" (
Bee Species | Number of Adult Males |
Eufriesea chrysopyga | 10 |
Eufriesea concava | 123 |
Eufriesea macroglossa | 33 |
Eufriesea mussitans | 1,025 |
Eufriesea rufocauda | 4 |
Eufriesea schmidtiana | 2 |
Euglossa allosticta | 43 |
Euglossa bursigera | 1 |
Euglossa championi | 21 |
Euglossa cybelia | 21 |
Euglossa deceptrix | 5 |
Euglossa dilemma | 227 |
Euglossa dissimula | 1 |
Euglossa dodsoni | 15 |
Euglossa dressleri | 1 |
Euglossa gorgonensis | 5 |
Euglossa hansoni | 7 |
Euglossa heterosticta | 6 |
Euglossa ignita | 5 |
Euglossa imperialis | 898 |
Euglossa macroglossa | 2 |
Euglossa maculilabris | 91 |
Euglossa mixta | 2 |
Euglossa purpurea | 2 |
Euglossa tridentata | 74 |
Euglossa turbinifex | 1 |
Euglossa variabilis | 29 |
Euglossa villosa | 1 |
Eulaema bombiformis | 4 |
Eulaema meriana | 8 |
Eulaema nigrita | 6 |
Eulaema polychroma | 7 |
Eulaema seabrai | 2 |
Exaerate smaragdina | 1 |
Exaerete frontalis | 58 |
Exaerete smaragdina | 1 |
Eufriesea mussitans (Fabricius, 1787)
Identification. Body 17-21 mm long. The clypeus has two strong sublateral ridges and a medial ridge. The medial ridge distinguishes E. mussitans from E. concava, the latter of which exhibits a concave area between the sublateral ridges.
Remarks. This species has been documented from “Mexico to south-eastern Brazil; lowlands up to 1,000 m” (
Eufriesea rufocauda (Kimsey, 1977)
Identification. Body ~ 14 mm long. Clypeus does not possess sublateral ridges. Face bronze below and green above in males. The anterior part of tergum II is dark and the posterior part of tergum II is reddish-copper with yellow hairs. In lateral view, male labrum has a square outline; when viewed dorsally, a pair of prominent conical points is visible. Differs from E. chrysopyga as: 1) E. chrysopyga has a uniformly purple tergum II; and 2) lateral view of male labrum of E. chrysopyga has a triangular outline and dorsal view reveals barely visible pair of conical points.
Remarks: In Costa Rica, E. rufocauda has been previously documented in Limon, Alajuela, Heredia and Guanacaste (North and in provinces on the Caribbean side) (
Euglossa dodsoni (Moure, 1965)
Identification. Body 10 mm long and reddish-bronze. Green clypeus and complete ivory eye bands. Basal tuft on the middle tibia is inconspicuous, thus appearing to have just one tuft. This distinguishes it clearly from very similar E. erythrochlora (not documented in this study), which has two apparent tibial tufts.
Remarks. This species has been documented from “Costa Rica to Columbia; lowlands up to at least 800 m” (
Euglossa dressleri (Moure, 1968)
Identification. Body 12 mm long and light green. Mesosoma is sometimes bronzish. Tongue is much shorter than the body. Clypeus is blue and the labrum has two distinct black spots. Ivory eye bands are absent. Two tufts are present and spaced well apart on the middle tibia, with distal tuft barely notched.
Remarks. In Costa Rica, E. dressleri has been documented in San Vito in Puntarenas and Peñas Blancas in Alajuela (
Euglossa hansoni (Moure, 1965)
Identification. Body 10 mm long and reddish-bronze or green. Thorax is shiny with shallow and reduced punctures. Tongue approximately the length of the body. Top of the head is predominantly green, sometimes with bronze. Ivory eye bands are complete and clypeus is blue. Middle tibia appears to have three tufts. Similar to E. alleni (not documented in this study) and E. purpurea, though E. alenni is very rare with less punctuation on tergum II and E. purpurea is more reddish with blackish clypeus.
Remarks. In Costa Rica, E. hansoni has been documented in Heredia, Limon and southern Puntarenas in the Osa Peninsula and the coastal nature preserve Refugio National de Fauna Silvestre Golfrio (
Euglossa ignita (Smith, 1874)
Identification. Body is 14-15 mm long with a green mesosoma and reddish-bronze metasoma. Tongue is longer than the body. Ivory bands are complete and clypeus is green. Broad longitudinal depression present in the middle of the scutellum. Two tufts on the middle tibia are touching, possibly appearing to be one tuft. Distal tuft is larger. A pair of widely separated diagonal slits is present on scutellum II, each with a dense row of setae.
Remarks. Euglossa ignita has been documented in all seven provinces in Costa Rica: Guanacaste, Alajuela, Heredia, Cartago, Limon and southern Puntarenas on the Osa Peninsula (
Euglossa tridentata (Moure, 1970)
Identification. Body is green and 11-12 mm long; tongue is much shorter than the body. Ivory eye bands are complete and clypeus is green. Three teeth on mandibles. Middle tibia has two tufts with distal tuft having a shallow notch. Similar to E. deceptrix and E. variabilis, though E. deceptrix and E. variabilis both have two teeth on the mandibles.
Remarks. In Costa Rica, E. tridentata has been recorded in Guanacaste, Alajuela, Heredia, Limon, San Jose and Puntarenas, outside of the Monteverde region (
Euglossa turbinifex (Dressler, 1978)
Identification. Body is 11 mm long and mostly green with a bluish-green mesosoma. Tongue is the length of the body. Mandibles have two teeth. Two tufts on the middle tibia, basal tuft larger than distal one. Sternum II has a pair of small semicircular depressions containing rows of setae. Similar to E. bursigera, but E. bursigera often has a more bronzish body and has three teeth on the mandible.
Remarks. In Costa Rica, E. turbinifex has been recorded in Alajuela, Heredia and Limon. In the GBIF database, less than 40 specimens are documented in total, 20 of them from Costa Rica (
Rank | Scientific Name |
---|---|
phylum | Arthropoda |
subphylum | Hexapoda |
class | Insecta |
order | Hymenoptera |
superfamily | Apoidea |
family | Apidae |
subfamily | Apinae |
tribe | Euglossini |
genus | Eufriesea |
genus | Euglossa |
genus | Eulaema |
genus | Exaerete |
9 January 2019 to 4 October 2019
This dataset contains 2,742 entries of Euglossine bees across four genera in Monteverde, Costa Rica (
Column label | Column description |
---|---|
institutionID | Identifier for the institution where database originates. |
collectionCode | Prefix of specimen code. |
catalogNumber | Full specinen code including collection code ("UGAEug" = UGA Euglossine) and specimen number in the collection. |
month | Month specimen was collected. |
verbatimEventDate | Date specimen was collected. |
country | The name of the country in which the Location occurs (Costa Rica). |
countryCode | ISO code of the country in which the location occurs. |
scientificName | Scientific name of specimen. |
sex | Sex of specimen (all male in this dataset). |
basisOfRecord | Specific nature of the data record. |
locality | Location of trap sites (University of Georgia Costa Rica campus). |
habitat | Habitat type (open area or forested area) in which specimen was caught. |
occurrenceRemarks | Vertical position of trap in which specimen was caught. Trap sites in forested areas possessed traps in both the canopy and understorey, whereas open area traps were only placed in one vertical position near the ground. Traps in open areas are labelled "open", as their vertical position was static. |
fieldNumber | Alphanumeric trap location code consisting of one letter ("F" or "O") and a number 1-10 (F = forest, O = open) |
decimalLongitude | Longitude of trap site |
decimalLatitude | Latitude of trap site |
geodeticDatum | The set of reference points on the Earth's surface upon which the geographic coordinates in "decimalLatitude" and "decimalLongitude" are based (WGS84, a constant). |
minimumElevationInMetres | Elevation (in metres) of trap site. |
recordedBy | Individual who collected specimen. |
coordinateUncertaintyInMetres | Uncertainty of the coordinates of the centre of the sampling area. |
rightsHolder | The organisation owning the rights over this resource (for this dataset, University of Georgia). |
class | Class name. |
collectionID | Identifier for the collection publishing the data. |
day | Day specimen was collected. |
year | Year sepcimen was collected. |
kingdom | Kingdom name. |
phylum | Phylum name. |
class | Class name. |
order | Order name. |
family | Family name. |
genus | Genus name. |
scientificNameAuthorship | Name of the author of the lowest taxon rank in the record. |
specificEpithet | Species epithet of the scientific name. |
day | Day the specimen was collected. |
year | Year in which the specimen was collected. |
accessRights | Information regarding who can access this information and use restrictions. |
taxonRank | The lowest taxonomic rank of the record. |
eventDate | Date the specimen was collected. |
occurrenceID | A global unique identifier for the occurrence. |
preparations | Preservation method of the specimen. |
startDayOfYear | Integer day on which specimen was collected. |
taxonID | Identifier for the set of taxon information (global identifier in this dataset). |
references | Reference page link for occurrence. |
modified | Date and time of last update. |
id | A unique identifier for the Symbiota Collection of Arthropods Network (SCAN). Equivalent here to eventID. |
preparations | Method of specimen preservation (mounted, in ethanol or frozen). |
recordID | A Universally Unique IDentifier (UUID) used to uniquely identify an object published to the internet, in this case an occurrence record. |
Due to changing climatic conditions and other anthropogenic effects, consistent sampling at various elevations is needed to track distributional changes in fauna over time. Shifting ranges are predicted as Euglossine bees respond to climate change (
This project and study design was originally conceived by José Joaquín Montero-Ramírez. Funding, housing, project materials and sampling sites were provided by Council on International Educational Exchange (CIEE) Global Instutute, Monteverde, Costa Rica campus, formerly University of Georgia, Costa Rica campus. Funding was provided by the D.B. Warnell School of Forestry and Natural Resources, University of Georgia and the Benjamin A. Gilman International Scholarship. Thank you to Kris Irwin (University of Georgia) for making this study possible by initiating contact with the University of Georgia Costa Rica faculty and approving and supporting the project. Thank you to Brandon Horn, Nathan Lasala, Alfonso Tascón, other resident naturalists and CIEE staff for moral, logistic, language and occasional field support. Special thanks to Ernest Minnema and Fabricio Camacho for helping reset canopy traps - without your help, field work would have been cut short. Neil Cobb (Northern Arizona University) and Joe McHugh (University of Georgia) assisted with data management.
Elise McDonald conducted fieldwork, identified and preserved specimens and wrote most of the manuscript. Jacob Podesta assited in developing the project, conducted field work, performed specimen identification and preservation and contributed to writing the manuscript. Christine Fortuin assisted with writing and analyses, georeferencing and creating maps. Kamal Gandhi oversaw the project after data collection and assisted with writing the manuscript.