Biodiversity Data Journal :
Research Article
|
Corresponding author: Liubov Kireenko (liubov.kireenko1996@gmail.com)
Academic editor: Anne Thessen
Received: 06 Jun 2022 | Accepted: 20 Jul 2022 | Published: 22 Jul 2022
© 2022 Liubov Kireenko, Anna Tikhonova, Nina Kozina, Alexander Matul
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Kireenko L, Tikhonova A, Kozina N, Matul A (2022) Image dataset of benthic foraminifera in multicorer and gravity corer sediments from north-western Scotland shelf (North Atlantic Ocean). Biodiversity Data Journal 10: e87457. https://doi.org/10.3897/BDJ.10.e87457
|
Geological studies in the seas and oceans often give preference to the study of benthic foraminifera, which are a widespread and taxonomically diverse group of shell protozoa. In this paper, we present an extensive image dataset produced during the detailed micropaleontological analysis of 146 samples of bottom sediments collected by multicorer and gravity corer AMK-5656 from the Westray Basin on the north-western Scotland shelf (North Atlantic Ocean). In total, 106 taxa (at species and genera level) of benthic foraminifera were identified and photographed using the high-resolution microscope camera. This dataset can aid as a guide for identification of the benthic foraminiferal taxa at the paleoecological studies, stratigraphic works and interregional paleoceanographic correlation in the North Atlantic Ocean.
benthic foraminifera, micropaleontology, Scotland shelf, North Atlantic Ocean, Quaternary sediments
The North Atlantic (NA) is one of the key areas of the thermohaline circulation system of currents that transfer the heat, salt, dissolved elements and gases and sedimentary matter to the Subarctic and Arctic regions. This circulation being a part of the large-scale circulation of the World Ocean affects the warming and cooling of the global climate and regional oceanography in the NA and Arctic (
In this article, we present a new extensive dataset of the microphotographic illustrations with taxonomic coverage for 106 benthic foraminiferal taxa (mostly as species and genera) from the latest Pleistocene to the the Holocene sediments in the Westray Basin on the north-western Scotland shelf (NWSS). The sediment material was collected in summer 2018 during the 71st cruise of the research vessel Akademic Mstislav Keldysh (
Previous studies described diverse and abundant benthic foraminiferal microfauna in the modern and the the Holocene sediments on and around the Scotland shelf and provided some microphotographs of the typical species (
We studied the benthic foraminiferal microfauna from the multicorer (MC) and gravity corer (GC) sediments on the AMK-5656 station obtained during the 71st cruise of the Russian research vessel Akademik Mstislav Keldysh in summer 2018 (
Location of studied sediment cores AMK-5656 MC and GC. Map sources are GEBCO at https://download.gebco.net and EMODnet at https://portal.emodnet-bathymetry.eu.
The NWSS is a shallow water region of western North Atlantic Ocean dominated by the warm saline surface water of the North Atlantic Current branch crossing the NWSS from west to east between Orkney and Shetland (
Bio-monitoring studies, based on the living fauna, indicate that the taxonomically diverse benthic foraminifers densely populate the high-latitude shelf areas (
Table
List of benthic foraminiferal taxa in station AMK-5656 from north-western Scotland shelf in North Atlantic.
Ammonia falsobeccarii (Rouvillois, 1974) |
Amphicoryna scalaris (Batsch, 1791) |
Amphicoryna separans (Brady, 1884) |
Astrononion gallowayi Loeblich & Tappan, 1953 = Astrononion hamadaense Asano, 1950 |
Bolivina albatrossi Cushman, 1922 |
Bolivina earlandi Parr, 1950 |
Bolivina inflata Heron-Allen & Earland, 1913 |
Bolivina limbata (Brady, 1881) = Loxostomina limbata (Brady, 1881) |
Bolivina pseudoplicata Heron-Allen & Earland, 1930 |
Bolivina spathulata (Williamson, 1858) |
Bolivina striatula Cushman, 1922 |
Bolivina subspinescens Cushman, 1922 |
Bolivina tortuosa (Brady, 1881) = Sigmavirgulina tortuosa (Brady, 1881) |
Bolivina sp. d'Orbigny, 1839 |
Bolivinellina pseudopunctata (Höglund, 1947) |
Brizalina alata (Seguenza, 1862) = Bolivina alata (Seguenza, 1862) |
Brizalina pygmaea (Brady, 1881) = Bolivina pygmaea (Brady, 1881) |
Buccella frigida (Cushman, 1922) = Buccella calida (Cushman & Cole, 1930) |
Bulimina aculeata d'Orbigny, 1826 |
Bulimina elongata d'Orbigny, 1846 |
Bulimina marginata d'Orbigny |
Cassidulina carinata Silvestri, 1896 |
Cassidulina laevigata d'Orbigny, 1826 |
Cassidulina obtusa Williamson, 1858 |
Cassidulina reniforme Nørvang, 1945 |
Cassidulina teretis Tappan, 1951 = Cassidulina neoteretis Seidenkrantz, 1995 |
Cassidulina sp. d'Orbigny, 1826 |
Cassidulinoides bradyi (Norman, 1881) |
Cornuspira involvens (Reuss, 1850) |
Cibicides refulgens Montfort, 1808 |
Cibicides lobatulus (Walker & Jacob, 1798) = Lobatula lobatula (Walker & Jacob, 1798) |
Cibicidoides wuellerstorfi (Schwager, 1866) |
Cibicides sp. Montfort, 1808 |
Discorbis sp. Lamarck, 1804 |
Eggerelloides scaber (Williamson, 1858) |
Elphidium clavatum Cushman, 1930 = Elphidium excavatum subsp. clavatum Cushman, 1930 |
Elphidium earlandi Cushman, 1936 |
Elphidium gerthi van Voorthuysen, 1957 = Cribroelphidium gerthi (van Voorthuysen, 1957) |
Elphidium sp. Montfort, 1808 |
Epistomaroides polystomelloides (Parker & Jones, 1865) |
Epistominella exigua (Brady, 1884) |
Epistominella vitrea Parker, 1953 = Eilohedra vitrea (Parker, 1953) |
Facetocochlea pulchra (Cushman, 1933) |
Fissurina sp. Reuss, 1850 |
Fursenkoina fusiformis (Williamson, 1858) = Stainforthia fusiformis (Williamson, 1858) |
Fursenkoina complanata (Egger, 1893) = Stainforthia loeblichi (Feyling-Hanssen, 1954) |
Fursenkoina texturata (Brady, 1884) |
Geminospira bradyi Bermúdez, 1952 |
Glabratella altispira Buzas, Smith & Beem, 1977 |
Globobulimina pacifica Cushman, 1927 = Laryngosigma lactea (Walker & Jacob, 1798) |
Globocassidulina subglobosa (Brady, 1881) |
Hyalinea balthica (Schröter, 1783) |
Islandiella norcrossi (Cushman, 1933) |
Lagena sp. Walker & Jacob, 1798 |
Lamarckina haliotidea (Heron-Allen & Earland, 1911) |
Lenticulina gibba (d'Orbigny, 1839) |
Massilina secans (d'Orbigny, 1826) = Quinqueloculina secans d'Orbigny, 1826 |
Melonis barleeanus (Williamson, 1858) = Melonis affinis (Reuss, 1851) |
Melonis pompilioides (Fichtel & Moll, 1798) |
Melonis sp. Montfort, 1808 |
Miliolinella subrotunda (Montagu, 1803) |
Mychostomina revertens (Rhumbler, 1906) |
Neoglabratella wiesneri (Parr, 1950) |
Neolenticulina variabilis (Reuss, 1850) |
Nonion pauperatum (Balkwill & Wright, 1885) = Subanomalina pauperata (Balkwill & Wright, 1885) |
Nonion sp. Montfort, 1808 |
Nonionella auricula Heron-Allen & Earland, 1930 |
Nonionella iridea Heron-Allen & Earland, 1932 |
Nonionoides turgidus (Williamson, 1858) |
Oolina sp. d'Orbigny, 1839 |
Patellina corrugata Williamson, 1858 |
Planorbulina mediterranensis d'Orbigny, 1826 |
Planulina sp. d'Orbigny, 1826 |
Procerolagena clavata (d'Orbigny, 1846) |
Pyrgo murrhina (Schwager, 1866) |
Pyrgo williamsoni (Silvestri, 1923) |
Quinqueloculina seminulum (Linnaeus, 1758) |
Quinqueloculina sp. d'Orbigny, 1826 |
Robertinoides bradyi (Cushman & Parker, 1936) |
Robertinoides sp. Höglund, 1947 |
Rosalina araucana d'Orbigny, 1839 = Valvulineria araucana (d'Orbigny, 1839) |
Rosalina auberii d'Orbigny, 1839 = Discorbis auberii (d'Orbigny, 1839) = Rotorbis auberii (d'Orbigny, 1839) |
Rosalina bertheloti d'Orbigny, 1839 = Discorbinella bertheloti (d'Orbigny, 1839) |
Rosalina bradyi (Cushman, 1915) = Rosalina anomala Terquem, 1875 |
Rosalina globularis d'Orbigny, 1826 |
Rosalina opercularis d'Orbigny, 1826 = Rosalina opercularis d'Orbigny, 1839 = Discorbina opercularis (d'Orbigny, 1839) |
Rosalina vilardeboana d'Orbigny, 1839 = Discorbis vilardeboanus (d'Orbigny, 1839) |
Rosalina sp. d'Orbigny, 1826 |
Sahulia conica (d'Orbigny, 1839) = Textularia conica d'Orbigny, 1839 |
Siphotextularia concava (Karrer, 1868) |
Spiroloculina depressa d'Orbigny, 1826 |
Spiroloculina excavata d'Orbigny, 1846 |
Spiroloculina sp. d'Orbigny, 1826 |
Spirillina viviparina Saidova, 1975 |
Spiroplectinella wrighti (Silvestri, 1903) |
Textularia sagittula Defrance, 1824 |
Triloculina elongata d'Orbigny in Fornasini, 1905 |
Triloculina trigonula (Lamarck, 1804) |
Triloculina trihedra Loeblich & Tappan, 1953 |
Trifarina angulosa (Williamson, 1858) |
Trifarina bradyi Cushman, 1923 |
Trifarina fluens (Todd in Cushman & McCulloch, 1948) |
Uvigerina peregrina Cushman, 1923 |
Uvigerina mediterranea Hofker, 1932 |
Valvulineria minuta (Schubert, 1904) = Discorbis minuta (Schubert, 1904) |
Valvulineria rugosa (d'Orbigny, 1839) = Discorbis rugosa (d'Orbigny, 1839) = Rosalina rugosa d'Orbigny, 1839 |
Station 5656 MC. 1 Brizalina pygmaea; 2 Brizalina alata, a,b lateral view; 3 Bolivina tortuosa; 4 Bulimina aculeata, a apertural view, b lateral view; 5 Bulimina marginata, a apertural view, b lateral view; 6 Bolivina pseudoplicata, 6a side view, 6b lateral view; 7 Bolivina pseudoplicata; 8,9 Bolivina earlandi, a side view, b lateral view; 10,11 Bolivina striatula, a side view, b lateral view. Scale 100 µm.
Station 5656 MC (continued). 12 Cassidulina carinata, a, b apertural view, c lateral view; 13 Cassidulina obtusa, a, b apertural view, c lateral view; 14 Cassidulina laevigata, a, b apertural view, c lateral view; 15 Cassidulina reniforme, a, b apertural view, c lateral view; 16 Cassidulina sp., cf. C. laevigata, a, b apertural view, c lateral view; 17 Cassidulina teretis, a, b apertural view, c lateral view; 18 Islandiella norcrossi, a, b apertural view, c lateral view; 19 Globocassidulina subglobosa, a side view, b apertural view, c lateral view. Scale 100 µm.
Station 5656 MC (continued). 20 Astrononion gallowayi, a side view, b apertural view, c lateral view; 21 Elphidium clavatum, a side view, b apertural view; 22 Elphidium earlandi, a side view, b apertural view, c lateral view; 23 Elphidium gerthi, a side view, b apertural view; 24 Nonionoides turgidus, a side view, b apertural view; 25 Nonionella iridea, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 26 Nonion pauperatum, a side view, b apertural view; 27 Nonionella auricula; 28 Nonion sp. cf. N. faba, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view. Scale 100 µm.
Station 5656 MС (continued). 29 Melonis barleeanus, a side view, b apertural view, c lateral view; 30 Melonis pompilioides, a side view, b apertural view; 31 Ammonia falsobeccarii, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 32 Hyalinea balthica, a side view, b apertural view; 33 Cibicides refulgens, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 34 Cibicides lobatulus, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 35 Epistomaroides polystomelloides, a side view, b apertural view; 36 Planulina ariminensis, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view. Scale 100 µm.
Station 5656 MC (continued). 37 Rosalina vilardeboana, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 38 Rosalina bradyi, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 39 Rosalina araucana, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 40 Rosalina auberii, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 41 Lamarckina haliotidea, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 42 Rosalina bertheloti, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 43 Rosalina opercularis, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 44 Rosalina globularis, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view. Scale 100 µm.
Station 5656 MC (continued). 45 Trifarina angulosa, a side view, b apertural view; 46 Trifarina bradyi, a side view, b apertural view; 47 Uvigerina mediterranea; 48 Uvigerina peregrina, a side view, b apertural view; 49 Fursenkoina fusiformis, a apertural view, b side view; 50 Fursenkoina complanata, a apertural view, b side view; 51 Geminospira bradyi, a apertural view, b side view; 52 Robertinoides sp., a side view, b lateral view; 53 Robertinoides bradyi, a apertural view, b side view; 54 Neolenticulina variabilis, a side view, b lateral view; 55 Lenticulina gibba; 56 Amphicoryna scalaris, a side view, b apertural view. Scale 100 µm.
Station 5656 MC (continued). 57 – 60 Fissurina sp.; 61,62 Lagena sp., a side view, b apertural view; 63 Oolina sp.; 64 Globobulimina pacifica, a side view, b apertural view; 65 Pyrgo williamsoni, a apertural view, b side view; 66 Quinqueloculina seminulum, a-c side view, d apertural view. Scale 100 µm.
Station 5656 MC (continued). 67 Miliolinella subrotunda, a side view, b apertural view, c lateral view; 68 Triloculina elongata, a side view, b apertural view; 69 Spiroloculina excavata, a, b side view, c apertural view; 70 Massilina secans, a, b side view, c apertural view; 71 Cornuspira involvens, a side view, b lateral view; 72 Epistominella exigua, a spiral view, b umbilical view; 73 Glabratella altispira, a spiral view, b umbilical view; 74 Patellina corrugate, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view. Scale 100 µm.
Station 5656 MC (continued). 75 Sp. cf. C. lobatulus juvenile test, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 76 Planorbulina mediterranensis, a spiral view, b umbilical view; 77 Discorbis sp., a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 78 Sahulia conica, a apertural view, b side view; 79 Sahulia conica, a, c side view, b apertural view; 80 Textularia sagittula, a side view, b lateral view; 81 Siphotextularia concava, a side view, b lateral view; 82 Eggerelloides scaber, a, c side view, b apertural view. Scale 100 µm.
Station 5656 GC. 1 Brizalina pygmaea, a side view, b apertural view; 2 Brizalina alata, a, b side view, c apertural view; 3 Bolivina spathulata, a side view, b apertural view; 4 Bolivina striatula, a side view, b apertural view; 5 Bolivina pseudoplicata, a side view, b apertural view; 6 Bolivina earlandi, a side view, b lateral view; 7 Bolivinellina pseudopunctata, a side view, b apertural view; 8 Bolivina albatrossi, a side view, b apertural view; 9 Bolivina inflata, a side view, b apertural view; 10 Bolivina limbata, a side view, b lateral view; 11 Bolivina sp., a side view, b lateral view; 12 Bolivina subspinescens, a side view, b lateral view; 13,14 Fursenkoina complanata, 13a apertural view, 13b side view; 15 Fursenkoina fusiformis, a side view, b, c apertural view; 16 Fursenkoina texturata, a side view, b apertural view. Scale 100 µm.
Station 5656 GC (continued). 17 Bulimina marginata, a side view, b apertural view; 18 Bulimina elongata, a side view, b apertural view; 19 Bulimina aculeata, a side view, b apertural view; 20 Bulimina aculeata, a side view, b apertural view; 21 Trifarina angulosa, a side view, b apertural view; 22 Trifarina fluens, a side view, b apertural view; 23 Trifarina bradyi, a side view, b apertural view; 24 Uvigerina peregrina, a side view, b apertural view; 25 Uvigerina mediterranea, a side view, b apertural view; 26 Amphicoryna scalaris, a side view, b apertural view; 27 Amphicoryna separans, a side view, b apertural view; 28 Neolenticulina variabilis, a side view, b apertural view; 29 Lenticulina gibba, a side view, b apertural view. Scale 100 µm.
Station 5656 GC (continued). 30 Cassidulina carinata, a side view, b apertural view; 31 Cassidulina laevigata, a side view, b apertural view; 32 Cassidulina obtusa, a apertural view, b lateral view; 33 Cassidulina reniforme, a apertural view, b lateral view; 34 Cassidulina teretis, a side view, b apertural view; 35 Cassidulinoides bradyi, a side view, b apertural view; 36,37 Cassidulina sp. cf C. laevigata a side view, b apertural view; 38 Islandiella norcrossi, a side view, b apertural view; 39,40 Globocassidulina subglobosa, a side view, b apertural view; 41 Buccella frigida, a spiral view, b umbilical view; 42 Epistominella vitrea, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 43 Epistominella exigua, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view. Scale 100 µm.
Station 5656 GC (continued). 44,45 Rosalina vilardeboana, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 46 Rosalina globularis, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 47 Rosalina bradyi, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 48 Rosalina opercularis, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 49 Rosalina bertheloti, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 50 Rosalina araucana, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 51 Rosalina sp., a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 52 Lamarckina haliotidea, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 53 Discorbis sp., a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view. Scale 100 µm.
Station 5656 GC (continued). 54 Discorbis sp., a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 55 Neoglabratella wiesneri, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 56 Cibicides lobatulus, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 57 Cibicidoides wuellerstorfi, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 58 Sp. cf. C. lobatulus juvenile test, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 59,60 Glabratella altispira, 59a spiral view, 59b umbilical view; 61 Patellina corrugata, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 62 Planorbulina mediterranensis, a spiral view, b umbilical view; 63 Valvulineria rugosa, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 64 Valvulineria minuta, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view. Scale 100 µm
Station 5656 GC (continued). 65 Elphidium clavatum, a side view, b apertural view; 66 Elphidium gerthi, a side view, b apertural view; 67 Elphidium sp. cf. E. magellanicum, a side view, b apertural view; 68 Elphidium earlandi, a side view, b apertural view; 69 Elphidium sp. cf. E. williamsoni, a side view, b apertural view; 70 Astrononion gallowayi, a side view, b apertural view; 71 Melonis pompilioides, a side view, b apertural view; 72 Melonis barleeanus, a side view, b apertural view; 73,74 Sp. cf. Haynesina depressula, a side view, b apertural view; 75 Ammonia falsobeccarii, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 76 Nonionella auricula; 77 Nonion pauperatum, a side view, b apertural view; 78 Nonionoides turgidus; 79 Nonionella iridea, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view. Scale 100 µm.
Station 5656 GC (continued). 80 Nonion sp., cf. N. faba, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 81,82 Robertinoides bradyi, a apertural view, b lateral view; 83 Geminospira bradyi, a apertural view, b lateral view; 84 Hyalinea balthica, a side view, b apertural view; 85 Sp.; 86 Mychostomina revertens, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 87 Spirillina viviparina, a spiral view, b apertural view, c umbilical view; 88 Cornuspira involvens, a side view, b apertural view; 89 Facetocochlea pulchra, a spiral view, b umbilical view; 90 Spiroloculina sp., a side view, b apertural view; 91 Spiroloculina depressa, a, b side view, c apertural view; 92 Globobulimina pacifica, a-c side view, d apertural view. Scale 100 µm.
Station 5656 GC (continued). 93 Pyrgo murrhina, a side view, b apertural view; 94 Pyrgo williamsoni, a side view, b apertural view; 95 Triloculina elongata, a side view, b apertural view; 96 Triloculina trigonula, a-c side view, d apertural view; 97 Triloculina trihedra, a, b side view, c apertural view; 98 Miliolinella subrotunda, a, b side view, c apertural view; 99 Massilina secans, a-c side view, d apertural view; 100 Quinqueloculina seminulum, a, b side view, c apertural view; 101 Quinqueloculina sp. cf. Q. seminulum; 102-106 Quinqueloculina sp. Scale 100 µm.
Station 5656GC (continued). 107-111 Fissurina sp.; 112,113 Lagena sp., a side view, b apertural view; 114 Procerolagena clavata, a side view, b apertural view; 115,116 Oolina sp. a side view, b apertural view; 117 Sp. cf. Asterorotalia pulchella, a, b side view; 118 Textularia sagittula, a, b side view, c apertural view; 119,120 Spiroplectinella wright, 119a, b side view, 119c apertural view, 120a side view, 120b apertural view; 121 Siphotextularia concava, a, b side view, b apertural view; 122,123 Sahulia conica, a side view, b apertural view. Scale 100 µm.
Studies of the radiocarbon dated sediment cores in Shetland-Orkney area of the NWSS (
Onboard, the retrieved MC and GC sediments were subsampled through every 1 cm and stored in the refrigerator. In the shore laboratory, we analysed 19 samples from the MC (every 1 cm) and 127 samples from the GC (every 5 cm). All samples were freeze-dried, weighed, washed in the distilled water through a sieve with mesh size of 63 µm as recommended in
The microphotograph tables with images of benthic foraminifers can be used in the practical micropaleontological work with the modern and Quaternary sediment samples from the high-latitude areas of the North Atlantic. They will help the species identification, description of the foraminiferal assemblages and interpretation of the micropaleontological data for the biostratigraphy and paleoecology.
The authors thank the head of the expedition S.V. Gladyshev, the deputy head of the expedition A. N. Novigatsky, A. A. Klyuvitkin, S.M. Isachenko, G.V. Malafeev and the entire scientific staff for their assistance in conducting the expedition. The authors express special gratitude to the captain and crew of the research vessel Akademik Mstislav Keldysh.
This work was funded by the Russian Foundation of Basic Research, project number 20-35-90093 and was carried out with partial support from the Russian Ministry of Education and Science, SIO theme No. 0128-2021-0006 (sediment sampling) and the Russian Science Foundation grant 21-17-00235 (micropaleontology).
Conceptualisation, L.K., A.T., N.K. and A.M.; Methodology, L.K.; Investigation, L.K. A.T. and N.K.; Resources, A.T. and N.K.; Data Curation, L.K.; Writing – Original Draft Preparation, L.K.; Writing – Review & Editing, A.T., N.K. and A.M; Visualisation, L.K.; Supervision, L.K.; Funding Acquisition, L.K. and A.M. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.
The authors declare no conflict of interest. The funders had no role in the design of the study; in the collection, analyses or interpretation of data; in the writing of the manuscript or in the decision to publish the results.